Analysis of editorial from The Hindu newspaper on July 02, 2026
Yes and no: On the erosion of India’s grassroots democracy
Gram sabhas must have the right to give or withhold consent
Grassroots DemocracyGram Sabha73rd AmendmentPESA ActPanchayati RajRural Development
Sentences
Sentence 1 of 20
English Original
A new report, based on Rural Development Ministry surveys,opensa rare data-backed windowinto the erosion of India’s grassroots democracy.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
A new report, based on Rural Development Ministry ,
A recently published official document that is created using research conducted by the government’s rural department
Part 2
opens
provides or makes available
Part 3
a rare window
an uncommon opportunity to see facts clearly using statistics and evidence rather than assumptions
Part 4
into the of India’s
regarding how local self-governance in Indian villages is slowly being destroyed or weakened
Context and Background
Ministry of Rural Development
The Ministry of Rural Development is a branch of the Government of India responsible for the socio-economic development of rural India. It oversees key national schemes such as the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act (MGNREGA) and programs aimed at improving rural infrastructure, housing, and livelihood security.
Sentence 2 of 20
English Original
Butwhere the state has framed the issue as one of “vibrancy”,the reporthighlightsa paradox.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
But
However / on the other hand
Part 2
where the state has the issue as one of “”
in the situation where the government describes the problem as merely a lack of active participation and energy
Part 3
the report
the document based on Rural Development surveys
Part 4
highlights
draws attention to or points out
Part 5
a
a situation that seems self-contradictory or absurd but in reality expresses a possible truth
Sentence 3 of 20
English Original
Itacknowledgesthat “participation fatigue” has kept citizens from engaging in gram sabhaswhereas its solutions, such as more meetings and oversight, are a recipe to further alienate the rural working class.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
It
The new report from the ministry
Part 2
acknowledges
accepts or admits the truth of something
Part 3
that “” has kept citizens from in
the fact that people are tired of attending meetings that do not produce results, which stops them from taking part in village council discussions
Part 4
whereas its solutions, such as more meetings and , are a further the rural
while the report’s recommendations (like holding more sessions and checking them strictly) will actually push poor villagers away because they cannot afford to lose work time
Sentence 4 of 20
English Original
The 73rd Amendmentempowersgram sabhas,butgovernmentshave reducedthemto clearinghouses for central and State schemes.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
The 73rd Amendment
The 1992 constitutional change in India that created the modern local village government system
Part 2
empowers
gives legal authority or power to
Part 3
gram sabhas
the village councils composed of all local voters
Part 4
but
however / on the contrary
Part 5
governments
the state and central political authorities
Part 6
have reduced
have downgraded or lowered in status
Part 7
them
the gram sabhas
Part 8
to for central and State
into mere agencies whose only job is to approve list of names and allocate funds for programs made in Delhi or state capitals, rather than planning their own work
Context and Background
The 73rd Constitutional Amendment Act
Passed in 1992 and coming into effect in April 1993, the 73rd Amendment Act added Part IX to the Constitution of India, establishing a uniform three-tier Panchayati Raj system. It constitutionally recognized the Gram Sabha (village assembly) as the foundation of this system, intended to perform functions and exercise powers at the village level as decided by state legislatures, thereby institutionalizing direct democracy at the grassroots.
Sentence 5 of 20
English Original
This fundamental aspectmust change.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
This aspect
This core practice of reducing local assemblies to mere scheme approvers
Part 2
must change
is required to become different
Sentence 6 of 20
English Original
However,in response to 18%-28% of respondents citing a lack of outcomes as the reason for low interest,the reportpushes forgreater use of the NIRNAY app and to upload meeting minutes in real-time.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
However,
On the other hand / nevertheless
Part 2
in response to 18%-28% of a lack of as the reason for low interest
answering the fact that about one-fourth of surveyed villagers said they do not attend meetings because nothing useful ever happens
Part 3
the report
the government survey document
Part 4
pushes for
demands or strongly recommends
Part 5
greater use of the NIRNAY app and to upload in
using the new digital application more, and putting the records of discussions online immediately
Context and Background
Panchayat NIRNAY App
The Panchayat NIRNAY (National Initiative for Rural India to Navigate, InnovAte and Resolve PanchaYat decisions) mobile app is a digital initiative launched by the Ministry of Panchayati Raj. Designed under the e-Panchayat Mission Mode Project, it allows for recording, uploading photos and videos of Gram Sabha proceedings, and tracking resolutions in real-time to bring transparency and resolve disputes regarding local decisions.
Sentence 7 of 20
English Original
In the real world,panchayat secretariesthushaveless timefacilitating discussioneven as lacklustre oversight has allowed officials to tell workers that their MGNREGA demands were ‘not entered in the system’ due to server errors.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
In the real world,
In practical everyday life on the ground, as opposed to theories or plans
Part 2
panchayat secretaries
the administrative officers responsible for maintaining panchayat records and executing decisions
Part 3
thus
therefore / as a result of this digital burden
Part 4
have
possess or hold
Part 5
less time
a smaller amount of time than required
Part 6
discussion
helping people talk and share ideas during meetings
Part 7
even as has allowed officials to tell workers that their demands were ‘not entered in the system’ due to server errors
while at the same time, poor supervision means government officers can easily make excuses to labourers that technical computer problems prevented their employment requests from being saved
Sentence 8 of 20
English Original
Similarly,that more than half of the barriers to participation are related to livelihoodscould pointas much to visibly systemic issues (such as the precarious nature of rural labour today) as to deliberate economic exclusion by the state,as scholars have highlighted.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
Similarly,
In the same way / likewise
Part 2
that more than half of the to participation are related to
the fact that over 50 percent of the obstacles stopping citizens from attending meetings are linked to their daily earning needs
Part 3
could point
might indicate or suggest
Part 4
as much to visibly issues (such as the nature of rural labour today) as to economic by the state,
equally to obvious deep-rooted problems (like how unstable and risky village work has become) and to purposeful actions by the government to keep poor people out of the economy
Part 5
as have
just like academic researchers have pointed out in their studies
Sentence 9 of 20
English Original
Butthe reportdoes not acknowledgesuch divergent possibilities.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
But
However / nevertheless
Part 2
the report
the study document under discussion
Part 3
does not acknowledge
refuses to recognize or admit
Part 4
such
different and contrasting potential explanations (systemic versus deliberate exclusion)
Sentence 10 of 20
English Original
Due to the state failing to institutionalise attendance as a paid component of social protection,gram sabhashave remaineda playground for the leisured elite such as landlords and contractors.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
Due to the state failing to attendance as a paid of ,
because the government did not make attending the village meeting a paid activity (like wage labour) under welfare schemes
Part 2
gram sabhas
the village general body meetings
Part 3
have remained
have continued to be in a particular state
Part 4
a for the such as landlords and contractors
a place dominated and controlled only by wealthy people (like landholders and business operators) who have free time to spare without losing wages
Sentence 11 of 20
English Original
According to the report,gram sabhasspend13% of the timeidentifying local issuesbutonly 4%discussing revenue generation.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
According to the report,
As stated or documented in the study findings
Part 2
gram sabhas
the village councils
Part 3
spend
use or allocate time for an activity
Part 4
13% of the time
about one-eighth of their meeting duration
Part 5
local issues
finding and listing the problems faced by the villagers
Part 6
but
however / on the contrary
Part 7
only 4%
a very small fraction of their meeting duration
Part 8
discussing
talking about how to earn money locally through taxes or other means to fund village work
Sentence 12 of 20
English Original
Butgram panchayatshave been systematically constrainedfrom raising their taxes,leaving them dependent on grants.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
But
However / on the other hand
Part 2
gram panchayats
the village-level local governments
Part 3
have been
have been continuously and purposely restricted or limited by higher authorities
Part 4
from raising their taxes,
from increasing or collecting local duties from residents
Part 5
leaving them on
making them rely completely on funds given by central and state governments
Sentence 13 of 20
English Original
The 14th and 15th Finance Commissions grantstiedpanchayat spendingto central priorities such as drinking water and sanitation,limiting local priorities to ‘flagship’ programmes such as the Jal Jeevan Mission and Swachh Bharat.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
The 14th and 15th Finance Commissions grants
The financial allocations recommended by India’s 14th and 15th constitutional bodies that decide how tax revenues are divided between central and state governments
Part 2
tied
connected or linked directly, restricting any independent choices
Part 3
panchayat spending
how the village councils spend their allocated money
Part 4
to central such as drinking water and ,
to the targets set by the central government, specifically clean water supply and public cleanliness systems
Part 5
local priorities to ‘’ programmes such as the Jal Jeevan Mission and Swachh Bharat
forcing the local village planning to focus only on major national welfare campaigns like the clean water initiative and the clean India campaign
Context and Background
Finance Commission & Tied Grants
The Finance Commission of India is a constitutional body established under Article 280 to recommend the division of tax revenues between the Union and the States, and to suggest principles for grants-in-aid to local bodies. In recent years, particularly under the 14th and 15th Finance Commissions, a significant portion of grants to Panchayats was classified as ‘tied grants,’ meaning the funds could only be spent on specific sectors mandated by the Centre, notably drinking water, rainwater harvesting, and sanitation, which critics argue undermines local self-governance.
Sentence 14 of 20
English Original
There isthusno incentive for citizens to attend a meeting if the funds are being earmarked by Delhi bureaucrats.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
There is
exists
Part 2
thus
therefore / as a consequence
Part 3
no for citizens to attend a meeting
no motivation or benefit for villagers to spend their day sitting in assembly sessions
Part 4
if the funds are being by Delhi
in the event that all the expenditures and money are already decided and locked by government administrators in the national capital
Sentence 15 of 20
English Original
The reportalsostatesthat Provisions of the Panchayats (Extension to the Scheduled Areas) (PESA) Act areas have “reasonably strong physical infrastructure”.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
The report
the research paper on rural governance
Part 2
also
in addition / furthermore
Part 3
states
expresses or writes formally
Part 4
that Provisions of the Panchayats (Extension to the Scheduled Areas) (PESA) Act areas have “ strong physical ”
the fact that the tribal districts covered by the PESA law possess fairly good roads, buildings, and facilities
Context and Background
PESA Act, 1996
The Provisions of the Panchayats (Extension to the Scheduled Areas) Act, 1996 (PESA) is a central legislation that extends the provisions of Part IX of the Constitution (relating to Panchayats) to the Fifth Schedule Areas (tribal-dominated areas in ten states). It recognizes the traditional rights of tribal communities over local resources and mandates that Gram Sabhas must have veto power and control over major decisions, including land acquisition, mineral prospecting, and management of minor forest produce.
Sentence 16 of 20
English Original
Under the PESA Act 1996 and related forest rights laws,gram sabhashavethe right to provide prior informed consent for land acquisition and mining.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
Under the PESA Act 1996 and related forest rights laws,
according to the legal provisions of the 1996 tribal self-governance act and forest protection rules
Part 2
gram sabhas
the local tribal village assemblies
Part 3
have
possess or hold
Part 4
the right to provide for land and mining
the legal power to agree or disagree beforehand to any government plans to take their land or start digging for minerals
Sentence 17 of 20
English Original
However,the stateroutinely bypassesthemorusesthe excuse of low participationto manufacture consent.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
However,
On the other hand / nevertheless
Part 2
the state
the government authorities and administrators
Part 3
regularly ignores or avoids dealing with the assemblies
Part 4
them
the gram sabhas
Part 5
or
alternatively
Part 6
uses
makes use of or employs
Part 7
the of low participation
the pretext that not enough villagers attended the meetings
Part 8
to
to artificially create the appearance of agreement or approval, often through manipulation or forgery
Sentence 18 of 20
English Original
The Hasdeo Arand protestswere rootedin this issue.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
The Hasdeo Arand protests
The long-standing environmental and indigenous tribal demonstrations against coal mining clearances in the Hasdeo forest region of Chhattisgarh
Part 2
were
had their origin or cause
Part 3
in this issue
in this exact problem of bypassing local village assembly approval
Context and Background
Hasdeo Arand Protests
Hasdeo Arand is one of the largest intact forest stretches in Central India, located in Chhattisgarh. It is home to diverse biodiversity and indigenous Gond tribal communities. The region has witnessed intense protests by local Gram Sabhas and environmental activists against coal block allocations and mining projects. The protests are rooted in allegations that mining clearances were obtained by forging Gram Sabha consent resolutions, thereby violating PESA and Forest Rights Act laws.
Sentence 19 of 20
English Original
There isa right to say ‘no’andthe statesimplyneedsto acknowledge it.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
There is
exists
Part 2
a right to say ‘no’
the legal and moral entitlement of local communities to refuse consent for projects affecting their lands
Part 3
and
furthermore / in addition
Part 4
the state
the government
Part 5
simply
merely / without making complications
Part 6
needs
requires or is obligated
Part 7
to it
to recognize and respect this veto power
Sentence 20 of 20
English Original
If ‘yes’ must be the only answer,the report’s grousesarea farce.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
If ‘yes’ must be the only answer,
in the event that the government expects the village councils to always agree and never reject projects
Part 2
the report’s
the complaints and concerns raised in the ministry’s document about low participation
Part 3
are
exist as
Part 4
a
a ridiculous sham or mockery, lacking any real meaning or sincerity
Sentence 1 of 20
Sentences Breakdown
Editorial Summary
5-Point Summary
1A new report based on Rural Development Ministry surveys highlights the erosion of grassroots democracy in India, noting a paradox between the state’s focus on vibrancy and actual rural alienation.
2Although the 73rd Amendment empowers gram sabhas, governments have reduced them to mere clearinghouses for central and State schemes.
3The report’s solutions, like pushing the NIRNAY app and real-time uploads of meeting minutes, burden secretaries and fail to address the lack of actual outcomes.
4Financial constraints and tied grants from Finance Commissions have restricted the autonomy of gram panchayats, leaving them dependent on central priorities.
5In PESA areas, the state routinely bypasses the prior informed consent of gram sabhas for mining and land acquisition, highlighting the need to respect their right to say no.
Tone of the Editorial
Critical
Why this tone?
The editorial adopts a critical tone towards the government’s approach to rural self-governance. It highlights a paradox where the state promotes digital solutions like the NIRNAY app under the banner of vibrancy, while systematically undermining the actual financial and decision-making power of gram sabhas, especially in resource-rich tribal areas where local consent is routinely bypassed.
Sentence 1 of 20
A new report, based on Rural Development Ministry surveys,opensa rare data-backed windowinto the erosion of India’s grassroots democracy.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
A new report, based on Rural Development Ministry surveys,
A recently published official document that is created using research conducted by the government’s rural department
Part 2
opens
provides or makes available
Part 3
a rare data-backed window
an uncommon opportunity to see facts clearly using statistics and evidence rather than assumptions
Part 4
into the erosion of India’s grassroots democracy
regarding how local self-governance in Indian villages is slowly being destroyed or weakened
Sentence 2 of 20
Butwhere the state has framed the issue as one of “vibrancy”,the reporthighlightsa paradox.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
But
However / on the other hand
Part 2
where the state has framed the issue as one of “vibrancy”
in the situation where the government describes the problem as merely a lack of active participation and energy
Part 3
the report
the document based on Rural Development surveys
Part 4
highlights
draws attention to or points out
Part 5
a paradox
a situation that seems self-contradictory or absurd but in reality expresses a possible truth
Sentence 3 of 20
Itacknowledgesthat “participation fatigue” has kept citizens from engaging in gram sabhaswhereas its solutions, such as more meetings and oversight, are a recipe to further alienate the rural working class.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
It
The new report from the ministry
Part 2
acknowledges
accepts or admits the truth of something
Part 3
that “participation fatigue” has kept citizens from engaging in gram sabhas
the fact that people are tired of attending meetings that do not produce results, which stops them from taking part in village council discussions
Part 4
whereas its solutions, such as more meetings and oversight, are a recipe to further alienate the rural working class
while the report’s recommendations (like holding more sessions and checking them strictly) will actually push poor villagers away because they cannot afford to lose work time
Sentence 4 of 20
The 73rd Amendmentempowersgram sabhas,butgovernmentshave reducedthemto clearinghouses for central and State schemes.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
The 73rd Amendment
The 1992 constitutional change in India that created the modern local village government system
Part 2
empowers
gives legal authority or power to
Part 3
gram sabhas
the village councils composed of all local voters
Part 4
but
however / on the contrary
Part 5
governments
the state and central political authorities
Part 6
have reduced
have downgraded or lowered in status
Part 7
them
the gram sabhas
Part 8
to clearinghouses for central and State schemes
into mere agencies whose only job is to approve list of names and allocate funds for programs made in Delhi or state capitals, rather than planning their own work
Sentence 5 of 20
This fundamental aspectmust change.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
This fundamental aspect
This core practice of reducing local assemblies to mere scheme approvers
Part 2
must change
is required to become different
Sentence 6 of 20
However,in response to 18%-28% of respondents citing a lack of outcomes as the reason for low interest,the reportpushes forgreater use of the NIRNAY app and to upload meeting minutes in real-time.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
However,
On the other hand / nevertheless
Part 2
in response to 18%-28% of respondents citing a lack of outcomes as the reason for low interest
answering the fact that about one-fourth of surveyed villagers said they do not attend meetings because nothing useful ever happens
Part 3
the report
the government survey document
Part 4
pushes for
demands or strongly recommends
Part 5
greater use of the NIRNAY app and to upload meeting minutes in real-time
using the new digital application more, and putting the records of discussions online immediately
Sentence 7 of 20
In the real world,panchayat secretariesthushaveless timefacilitating discussioneven as lacklustre oversight has allowed officials to tell workers that their MGNREGA demands were ‘not entered in the system’ due to server errors.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
In the real world,
In practical everyday life on the ground, as opposed to theories or plans
Part 2
panchayat secretaries
the administrative officers responsible for maintaining panchayat records and executing decisions
Part 3
thus
therefore / as a result of this digital burden
Part 4
have
possess or hold
Part 5
less time
a smaller amount of time than required
Part 6
facilitating discussion
helping people talk and share ideas during meetings
Part 7
even as lacklustre oversight has allowed officials to tell workers that their MGNREGA demands were ‘not entered in the system’ due to server errors
while at the same time, poor supervision means government officers can easily make excuses to labourers that technical computer problems prevented their employment requests from being saved
Sentence 8 of 20
Similarly,that more than half of the barriers to participation are related to livelihoodscould pointas much to visibly systemic issues (such as the precarious nature of rural labour today) as to deliberate economic exclusion by the state,as scholars have highlighted.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
Similarly,
In the same way / likewise
Part 2
that more than half of the barriers to participation are related to livelihoods
the fact that over 50 percent of the obstacles stopping citizens from attending meetings are linked to their daily earning needs
Part 3
could point
might indicate or suggest
Part 4
as much to visibly systemic issues (such as the precarious nature of rural labour today) as to deliberate economic exclusion by the state,
equally to obvious deep-rooted problems (like how unstable and risky village work has become) and to purposeful actions by the government to keep poor people out of the economy
Part 5
as scholars have highlighted
just like academic researchers have pointed out in their studies
Sentence 9 of 20
Butthe reportdoes not acknowledgesuch divergent possibilities.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
But
However / nevertheless
Part 2
the report
the study document under discussion
Part 3
does not acknowledge
refuses to recognize or admit
Part 4
such divergent possibilities
different and contrasting potential explanations (systemic versus deliberate exclusion)
Sentence 10 of 20
Due to the state failing to institutionalise attendance as a paid component of social protection,gram sabhashave remaineda playground for the leisured elite such as landlords and contractors.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
Due to the state failing to institutionalise attendance as a paid component of social protection,
because the government did not make attending the village meeting a paid activity (like wage labour) under welfare schemes
Part 2
gram sabhas
the village general body meetings
Part 3
have remained
have continued to be in a particular state
Part 4
a playground for the leisured elite such as landlords and contractors
a place dominated and controlled only by wealthy people (like landholders and business operators) who have free time to spare without losing wages
Sentence 11 of 20
According to the report,gram sabhasspend13% of the timeidentifying local issuesbutonly 4%discussing revenue generation.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
According to the report,
As stated or documented in the study findings
Part 2
gram sabhas
the village councils
Part 3
spend
use or allocate time for an activity
Part 4
13% of the time
about one-eighth of their meeting duration
Part 5
identifying local issues
finding and listing the problems faced by the villagers
Part 6
but
however / on the contrary
Part 7
only 4%
a very small fraction of their meeting duration
Part 8
discussing revenue generation
talking about how to earn money locally through taxes or other means to fund village work
Sentence 12 of 20
Butgram panchayatshave been systematically constrainedfrom raising their taxes,leaving them dependent on grants.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
But
However / on the other hand
Part 2
gram panchayats
the village-level local governments
Part 3
have been systematically constrained
have been continuously and purposely restricted or limited by higher authorities
Part 4
from raising their taxes,
from increasing or collecting local duties from residents
Part 5
leaving them dependent on grants
making them rely completely on funds given by central and state governments
Sentence 13 of 20
The 14th and 15th Finance Commissions grantstiedpanchayat spendingto central priorities such as drinking water and sanitation,limiting local priorities to ‘flagship’ programmes such as the Jal Jeevan Mission and Swachh Bharat.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
The 14th and 15th Finance Commissions grants
The financial allocations recommended by India’s 14th and 15th constitutional bodies that decide how tax revenues are divided between central and state governments
Part 2
tied
connected or linked directly, restricting any independent choices
Part 3
panchayat spending
how the village councils spend their allocated money
Part 4
to central priorities such as drinking water and sanitation,
to the targets set by the central government, specifically clean water supply and public cleanliness systems
Part 5
limiting local priorities to ‘flagship’ programmes such as the Jal Jeevan Mission and Swachh Bharat
forcing the local village planning to focus only on major national welfare campaigns like the clean water initiative and the clean India campaign
Sentence 14 of 20
There isthusno incentive for citizens to attend a meeting if the funds are being earmarked by Delhi bureaucrats.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
There is
exists
Part 2
thus
therefore / as a consequence
Part 3
no incentive for citizens to attend a meeting
no motivation or benefit for villagers to spend their day sitting in assembly sessions
Part 4
if the funds are being earmarked by Delhi bureaucrats
in the event that all the expenditures and money are already decided and locked by government administrators in the national capital
Sentence 15 of 20
The reportalsostatesthat Provisions of the Panchayats (Extension to the Scheduled Areas) (PESA) Act areas have “reasonably strong physical infrastructure”.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
The report
the research paper on rural governance
Part 2
also
in addition / furthermore
Part 3
states
expresses or writes formally
Part 4
that Provisions of the Panchayats (Extension to the Scheduled Areas) (PESA) Act areas have “reasonably strong physical infrastructure”
the fact that the tribal districts covered by the PESA law possess fairly good roads, buildings, and facilities
Sentence 16 of 20
Under the PESA Act 1996 and related forest rights laws,gram sabhashavethe right to provide prior informed consent for land acquisition and mining.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
Under the PESA Act 1996 and related forest rights laws,
according to the legal provisions of the 1996 tribal self-governance act and forest protection rules
Part 2
gram sabhas
the local tribal village assemblies
Part 3
have
possess or hold
Part 4
the right to provide prior informed consent for land acquisition and mining
the legal power to agree or disagree beforehand to any government plans to take their land or start digging for minerals
Sentence 17 of 20
However,the stateroutinely bypassesthemorusesthe excuse of low participationto manufacture consent.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
However,
On the other hand / nevertheless
Part 2
the state
the government authorities and administrators
Part 3
routinely bypasses
regularly ignores or avoids dealing with the assemblies
Part 4
them
the gram sabhas
Part 5
or
alternatively
Part 6
uses
makes use of or employs
Part 7
the excuse of low participation
the pretext that not enough villagers attended the meetings
Part 8
to manufacture consent
to artificially create the appearance of agreement or approval, often through manipulation or forgery
Sentence 18 of 20
The Hasdeo Arand protestswere rootedin this issue.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
The Hasdeo Arand protests
The long-standing environmental and indigenous tribal demonstrations against coal mining clearances in the Hasdeo forest region of Chhattisgarh
Part 2
were rooted
had their origin or cause
Part 3
in this issue
in this exact problem of bypassing local village assembly approval
Sentence 19 of 20
There isa right to say ‘no’andthe statesimplyneedsto acknowledge it.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
There is
exists
Part 2
a right to say ‘no’
the legal and moral entitlement of local communities to refuse consent for projects affecting their lands
Part 3
and
furthermore / in addition
Part 4
the state
the government
Part 5
simply
merely / without making complications
Part 6
needs
requires or is obligated
Part 7
to acknowledge it
to recognize and respect this veto power
Sentence 20 of 20
If ‘yes’ must be the only answer,the report’s grousesarea farce.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
If ‘yes’ must be the only answer,
in the event that the government expects the village councils to always agree and never reject projects
Part 2
the report’s grouses
the complaints and concerns raised in the ministry’s document about low participation
Part 3
are
exist as
Part 4
a farce
a ridiculous sham or mockery, lacking any real meaning or sincerity
Reading Comprehension
Practice questions based on this editorial
Reading Comprehension - Yes and no: On the erosion of India’s grassroots democracy
Practice reading comprehension questions based on the editorial about the erosion of grassroots democracy in India, the PESA Act, and the NIRNAY app.
Scoreclever helps you master Current Affairs, English Language, and General Awareness for all Banking, SSC, Railway, and Defence exams. The Scoreclever app has innovative learning techniques that make memorization and revision effortless.