The Hindu Editorial • February 19, 2026 • Read Original

Troubled waters: On the Great Nicobar Project

Concerns about the Nicobar project should have got a fair appraisal

Scoreclever

Win Exams Cleverly

The Hindu Read Original

12 min read

Analysis of editorial from The Hindu newspaper on February 19, 2026

Troubled waters: On the Great Nicobar Project

Concerns about the Nicobar project should have got a fair appraisal

Great Nicobar ProjectNational Green TribunalEnvironmental ConservationTribal RightsSustainable Development

Sentences

Sentence 1 of 16

English Original

Proponents of the controversial Great Nicobar Project will be enthused by an order from the Kolkata bench of the National Green Tribunal (NGT) ruling that all environmental safeguards are in place, that the potential impact of this gargantuan project on resident native populations of the region is duly accounted for, and the project’s “strategic utility” is reason enough for the government to not be fully transparent with what it shares in the public domain.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

of the Great Nicobar Project

People who support the debated plan to build big structures on Great Nicobar island

Part 2

will be

Will feel very happy and encouraged

Part 3

by an order from the National Green Tribunal ruling that safeguards are in place, impacts are accounted for, and justifies secrecy

Because a special environmental court decided the project is safe, follows environmental rules, and is important enough to keep some parts private

Context and Background

The Great Nicobar Project and NGT

The Great Nicobar Project is a mega-infrastructure project planned for the southernmost tip of India. It includes an international trans-shipment port, an airport, and a power plant. The National Green Tribunal (NGT), which oversees environmental disputes, recently cleared the project despite several petitions raising concerns about its impact on the island’s unique biodiversity and indigenous tribes like the Shompen.

Sentence 2 of 16

English Original

But the dominant narrative around the project mirrors the classic development versus environment conflict of a pristine Pandora being ravaged for the greed of far-away mainlanders.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

But

However (introducing a contrasting idea)

Part 2

the around the project

The most common and popular story or way people talk about the project

Part 3

Looks exactly like or reflects

Part 4

the classic development versus environment conflict of a being for the greed of far-away

The old fight between building for money and protecting nature, where a beautiful untouched place is destroyed by people from distant cities for their own benefit

Context and Background

Allusion to

The term ‘Pandora’ here likely refers to two things: First, the mythical ‘Pandora’s Box’ which, when opened, releases many evils. Second, it is a strong allusion to the 2009 movie <em>Avatar</em>, where a pristine moon called Pandora is destroyed by ‘mainlanders’ (humans from Earth) for a valuable mineral, mirroring the conflict between big development projects and the protection of untouched island ecosystems.

Sentence 3 of 16

English Original

The Great Nicobar Island Project (GNIP) envisages a trans-shipment port, an international airport, township development, and a 450 Megavolt-Amperes (MVA) gas and solar-based power plant.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

The Great Nicobar Island Project (GNIP)

The name of the massive development plan for the island

Part 2

Plans for or imagines as a future possibility

Part 3

a , an international airport, , and a 450 gas and solar-based power plant

A port where big ships exchange cargo, a global airport, a new city, and a large power station using gas and the sun

Sentence 4 of 16

English Original

In the early 20th century, the British Phosphate Commissioners (a joint venture of the U.K., Australia, and New Zealand) began large-scale phosphate mining for fertilizer on Nauru and Banaba in the Pacific Ocean.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

In the early 20th century

In the early 1900s

Part 2

the British Phosphate Commissioners (a of the U.K., Australia, and New Zealand)

A group created by the governments of the UK, Australia, and New Zealand to work together

Part 3

began

Started

Part 4

large-scale mining for

Digging up huge amounts of phosphate (a mineral) to make food for plants

Part 5

on Nauru and Banaba in the Pacific Ocean

On two small islands located far away in the Pacific Ocean

Sentence 5 of 16

English Original

By 1945, the island had been so physically devastated by strip mining that it was deemed uninhabitable.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

By 1945

By the end of the second World War

Part 2

the island

The island of Banaba

Part 3

had been so physically

Had been completely broken and destroyed

Part 4

By a mining method that removes the entire top layer of soil

Part 5

that it was

Which made people decide that it was impossible for humans to live there

Sentence 6 of 16

English Original

The native Banabans were forcibly relocated to Rabi Island in Fiji, over 2,000 kilometres away.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

The native Banabans

The original people who lived on Banaba island

Part 2

were

Were moved to a new place by force, against their will

Part 3

to Rabi Island in Fiji, over 2,000 kilometres away

To another island in the country of Fiji, which was a huge distance (more than 2,000 km) from their home

Sentence 7 of 16

English Original

Today, Banaba is a desolate landscape of jagged limestone “pinnacles” and the displaced population is fighting for the rehabilitation of its homeland.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

Today

In the present time

Part 2

Banaba

The island we are discussing

Part 3

Exists currently as

Part 4

a landscape of limestone “”

A lonely, empty place filled with sharp, pointed rocks

Part 5

the population

The group of people who were forced out of their own land

Part 6

is fighting

Is struggling or pushing hard for something

Part 7

for the of its homeland

To have their home repaired and restored so they can live there again

Sentence 8 of 16

English Original

These serve as historical precedents for why economic logic alone cannot dictate actions in remote territories.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

These

The historical examples of Nauru and Banaba that were just described

Part 2

serve

Act as or or provide

Part 3

as historical for why alone cannot actions in

As lessons from the past showing that we cannot make decisions about distant islands based only on money and profit

Sentence 9 of 16

English Original

Though accorded an environment and preliminary forest clearance by the Union Environment Ministry, concerns about the potential loss of biodiversity, tree-felling, and impact on resident tribes prompted the NGT to order a review of the environmental aspects of the project.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

Though an environment and by the Union Environment Ministry

Even though the central government’s environment department already gave the first few permissions

Part 2

concerns about the potential loss of , , and impact on

Serious worries about damaging the variety of life, cutting down trees, and affecting the local people living there

Part 3

Caused or made someone take action

Part 4

the NGT

The National Green Tribunal (India’s environmental court)

Part 5

to order a review of the environmental aspects of the project

To command a formal re-examination of how the project affects nature

Sentence 10 of 16

English Original

Independent scientists and environmentalist groups have said that the felling of tracts of pristine tropical forest — nearly nine lakh trees across 130 sq.km — for this project would significantly harm the biodiversity of the region and constitute an irreparable loss.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

Independent scientists and environmentalist groups

Experts and organizations that work to protect nature and are not controlled by the government

Part 2

have said

Have stated or warned

Part 3

that the of of tropical forest — nearly nine trees across 130 sq.km — for this project would the biodiversity of the region and an

That cutting down huge areas of untouched forests (about 9 lakh trees) will deeply damage local wildlife and cause a permanent loss that can never be fixed

Context and Background

Scale of the Forest Loss

The clearing of 130 sq. km of forest is a massive undertaking; for comparison, this area is larger than the city of Chandigarh (114 sq. km). Felling nearly 9 lakh (900,000) trees in such a small island ecosystem is unprecedented in India and could eliminate unique species found nowhere else on Earth.

Sentence 11 of 16

English Original

This is not counting the disturbance to leatherback turtle nesting grounds and the assault on the corals.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

This

The damage from cutting down trees mentioned earlier

Part 2

is not counting

Does not even include (meaning there are many more problems)

Part 3

the disturbance to and the on the

The trouble caused to the places where giant turtles lay eggs and the severe damage to the underwater sea life (corals)

Context and Background

Leatherback Turtles and Galathea Bay

Galathea Bay on Great Nicobar Island is one of the world’s most important nesting sites for the giant Leatherback turtle. To build the port, the government ‘denotified’ (cancelled the protected status of) the Galathea Bay Wildlife Sanctuary, which environmentalists fear will lead to the extinction of this turtle population in the region. The project also involves moving or destroying thousands of coral colonies.

Sentence 12 of 16

English Original

There was also the contested matter of whether the community rights of the local Shompen and the Nicobarese tribes were fully settled under the requirements of the Forest Rights Act.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

There

(Used to start a sentence about the existence of something)

Part 2

was

Existed

Part 3

also

In addition to the environmental problems

Part 4

the of whether the of the local Shompen and the Nicobarese tribes were fully under the requirements of the

The disputed question of if the land and resource rights of the local tribes were officially finished and protected according to the law

Context and Background

Tribal Rights and the FRA

The Forest Rights Act (FRA) of 2006 requires the government to recognize the rights of tribes over their ancestral forests before any land can be used for projects. The Shompen are a ‘Particularly Vulnerable Tribal Group’ (PVTG) living in isolation. Activists argue the government hurried the process and didn’t properly get the tribes’ consent, which is a legal requirement under the FRA.

Sentence 13 of 16

English Original

Recently, members of the Tribal Council said they were being coerced to sign “surrender certificates” that implied their consent to large parts of their land being diverted for the project.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

Recently

In the last few months or weeks

Part 2

members of the Tribal Council

The group of leaders who represent and make decisions for the local tribes

Part 3

said

Reported or stated

Part 4

they were being to sign “” that their to large parts of their land being for the project

That they were forced by pressure to sign papers giving up their land, which then made it look like they agreed to the construction plan

Sentence 14 of 16

English Original

The NGT order essentially rubber-stamps the government’s appraisal process without independently examining the concerns raised.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

The NGT order

The legal decision made by the National Green Tribunal (environmental court)

Part 2

essentially

Basically or in its most important part

Part 3

Gives official approval to something without checking it carefully

Part 4

the government’s

The system the government used to check if the project was safe and good

Part 5

without examining the

Without looking at the complaints on its own instead of just trusting the government’s report

Sentence 15 of 16

English Original

It only imposes faith that the government will be a conscientious executor of the project.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

The NGT order

Part 2

only

Just or merely (implying this is not enough)

Part 3

Forces a requirement or a situation upon someone

Part 4

faith

Trust or belief that someone will do the right thing

Part 5

that the government will be a of the project

That the government will perform its duties carefully and honestly while building the project

Sentence 16 of 16

English Original

Whether the Great Nicobar Project is a ‘net good’ can only be judged by future generations, but the lack of a process that offers a fair appraisal of independent concerns bodes ill for the present.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

Whether the Great Nicobar Project is a ‘’

If the whole plan is actually more helpful than harmful in the end

Part 2

can only be judged

Can only be decided or understood

Part 3

by future generations

By the people who will live on Earth many years from now

Part 4

the lack of a process that offers a of

The fact that there is no proper system to honestly and fairly check the worries of outside experts

Part 5

Is a sign of or suggests a future outcome

Part 6

ill

Badly or poorly

Part 7

for the present

For the current time we are living in

Sentence 1 of 16

Sentences Breakdown

Editorial Summary

5-Point Summary

1 The National Green Tribunal (NGT) recently cleared the Great Nicobar Project, stating all environmental safeguards and tribal impacts are addressed.
2 The editorial highlights a sharp conflict between massive development plans (port, airport, power plant) and the preservation of a pristine ecosystem.
3 A historical comparison with phosphate mining in Nauru and Banaba serves as a warning against prioritizing economic logic over environmental habitability.
4 Serious concerns persist regarding the loss of biodiversity, massive tree-felling, and the potential violation of tribal rights under the Forest Rights Act.
5 The editorial concludes that the NGT’s failure to independently examine these concerns and its reliance on government appraisal bodes ill for the region’s future.

Tone of the Editorial

Critical

Why this tone?

The editorial takes a critical stance toward the National Green Tribunal’s approval of the Great Nicobar Project. It uses phrases like “rubber-stamps the government’s appraisal process,” “bodes ill for the present,” and “greed of far-away mainlanders” to express strong disapproval and skepticism about the project’s oversight and impact.

Sentence 1 of 16

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

Proponents of the controversial Great Nicobar Project

People who support the debated plan to build big structures on Great Nicobar island

Part 2

will be enthused

Will feel very happy and encouraged

Part 3

by an order from the National Green Tribunal ruling that safeguards are in place, impacts are accounted for, and strategic utility justifies secrecy

Because a special environmental court decided the project is safe, follows environmental rules, and is important enough to keep some parts private

Sentence 2 of 16

But the dominant narrative around the project mirrors the classic development versus environment conflict of a pristine Pandora being ravaged for the greed of far-away mainlanders.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

But

However (introducing a contrasting idea)

Part 2

the dominant narrative around the project

The most common and popular story or way people talk about the project

Part 3

mirrors

Looks exactly like or reflects

Part 4

the classic development versus environment conflict of a pristine Pandora being ravaged for the greed of far-away mainlanders

The old fight between building for money and protecting nature, where a beautiful untouched place is destroyed by people from distant cities for their own benefit

Sentence 3 of 16

The Great Nicobar Island Project (GNIP) envisages a trans-shipment port, an international airport, township development, and a 450 Megavolt-Amperes (MVA) gas and solar-based power plant.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

The Great Nicobar Island Project (GNIP)

The name of the massive development plan for the island

Part 2

envisages

Plans for or imagines as a future possibility

Part 3

a trans-shipment port, an international airport, township development, and a 450 Megavolt-Amperes (MVA) gas and solar-based power plant

A port where big ships exchange cargo, a global airport, a new city, and a large power station using gas and the sun

Sentence 4 of 16

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

In the early 20th century

In the early 1900s

Part 2

the British Phosphate Commissioners (a joint venture of the U.K., Australia, and New Zealand)

A group created by the governments of the UK, Australia, and New Zealand to work together

Part 3

began

Started

Part 4

large-scale phosphate mining for fertilizer

Digging up huge amounts of phosphate (a mineral) to make food for plants

Part 5

on Nauru and Banaba in the Pacific Ocean

On two small islands located far away in the Pacific Ocean

Sentence 5 of 16

By 1945, the island had been so physically devastated by strip mining that it was deemed uninhabitable.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

By 1945

By the end of the second World War

Part 2

the island

The island of Banaba

Part 3

had been so physically devastated

Had been completely broken and destroyed

Part 4

by strip mining

By a mining method that removes the entire top layer of soil

Part 5

that it was deemed uninhabitable

Which made people decide that it was impossible for humans to live there

Sentence 6 of 16

The native Banabans were forcibly relocated to Rabi Island in Fiji, over 2,000 kilometres away.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

The native Banabans

The original people who lived on Banaba island

Part 2

were forcibly relocated

Were moved to a new place by force, against their will

Part 3

to Rabi Island in Fiji, over 2,000 kilometres away

To another island in the country of Fiji, which was a huge distance (more than 2,000 km) from their home

Sentence 7 of 16

Today, Banaba is a desolate landscape of jagged limestone “pinnacles” and the displaced population is fighting for the rehabilitation of its homeland.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

Today

In the present time

Part 2

Banaba

The island we are discussing

Part 3

Exists currently as

Part 4

a desolate landscape of jagged limestone “pinnacles”

A lonely, empty place filled with sharp, pointed rocks

Part 5

the displaced population

The group of people who were forced out of their own land

Part 6

is fighting

Is struggling or pushing hard for something

Part 7

for the rehabilitation of its homeland

To have their home repaired and restored so they can live there again

Sentence 8 of 16

These serve as historical precedents for why economic logic alone cannot dictate actions in remote territories.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

These

The historical examples of Nauru and Banaba that were just described

Part 2

serve

Act as or or provide

Part 3

as historical precedents for why economic logic alone cannot dictate actions in remote territories

As lessons from the past showing that we cannot make decisions about distant islands based only on money and profit

Sentence 9 of 16

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

Though accorded an environment and preliminary forest clearance by the Union Environment Ministry

Even though the central government’s environment department already gave the first few permissions

Part 2

concerns about the potential loss of biodiversity, tree-felling, and impact on resident tribes

Serious worries about damaging the variety of life, cutting down trees, and affecting the local people living there

Part 3

prompted

Caused or made someone take action

Part 4

the NGT

The National Green Tribunal (India’s environmental court)

Part 5

to order a review of the environmental aspects of the project

To command a formal re-examination of how the project affects nature

Sentence 10 of 16

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

Independent scientists and environmentalist groups

Experts and organizations that work to protect nature and are not controlled by the government

Part 2

have said

Have stated or warned

Part 3

that the felling of tracts of pristine tropical forest — nearly nine lakh trees across 130 sq.km — for this project would significantly harm the biodiversity of the region and constitute an irreparable loss

That cutting down huge areas of untouched forests (about 9 lakh trees) will deeply damage local wildlife and cause a permanent loss that can never be fixed

Sentence 11 of 16

This is not counting the disturbance to leatherback turtle nesting grounds and the assault on the corals.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

This

The damage from cutting down trees mentioned earlier

Part 2

is not counting

Does not even include (meaning there are many more problems)

Part 3

the disturbance to leatherback turtle nesting grounds and the assault on the corals

The trouble caused to the places where giant turtles lay eggs and the severe damage to the underwater sea life (corals)

Sentence 12 of 16

There was also the contested matter of whether the community rights of the local Shompen and the Nicobarese tribes were fully settled under the requirements of the Forest Rights Act.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

There

(Used to start a sentence about the existence of something)

Part 2

was

Existed

Part 3

also

In addition to the environmental problems

Part 4

the contested matter of whether the community rights of the local Shompen and the Nicobarese tribes were fully settled under the requirements of the Forest Rights Act

The disputed question of if the land and resource rights of the local tribes were officially finished and protected according to the law

Sentence 13 of 16

Recently, members of the Tribal Council said they were being coerced to sign “surrender certificates” that implied their consent to large parts of their land being diverted for the project.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

Recently

In the last few months or weeks

Part 2

members of the Tribal Council

The group of leaders who represent and make decisions for the local tribes

Part 3

said

Reported or stated

Part 4

they were being coerced to sign “surrender certificates” that implied their consent to large parts of their land being diverted for the project

That they were forced by pressure to sign papers giving up their land, which then made it look like they agreed to the construction plan

Sentence 14 of 16

The NGT order essentially rubber-stamps the government’s appraisal process without independently examining the concerns raised.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

The NGT order

The legal decision made by the National Green Tribunal (environmental court)

Part 2

essentially

Basically or in its most important part

Part 3

rubber-stamps

Gives official approval to something without checking it carefully

Part 4

the government’s appraisal process

The system the government used to check if the project was safe and good

Part 5

without independently examining the concerns raised

Without looking at the complaints on its own instead of just trusting the government’s report

Sentence 15 of 16

It only imposes faith that the government will be a conscientious executor of the project.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

The NGT order

Part 2

only

Just or merely (implying this is not enough)

Part 3

imposes

Forces a requirement or a situation upon someone

Part 4

faith

Trust or belief that someone will do the right thing

Part 5

that the government will be a conscientious executor of the project

That the government will perform its duties carefully and honestly while building the project

Sentence 16 of 16

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

Whether the Great Nicobar Project is a ‘net good’

If the whole plan is actually more helpful than harmful in the end

Part 2

can only be judged

Can only be decided or understood

Part 3

by future generations

By the people who will live on Earth many years from now

Part 4

the lack of a process that offers a fair appraisal of independent concerns

The fact that there is no proper system to honestly and fairly check the worries of outside experts

Part 5

bodes

Is a sign of or suggests a future outcome

Part 6

ill

Badly or poorly

Part 7

for the present

For the current time we are living in

Reading Comprehension

Practice questions based on this editorial

Reading Comprehension - Great Nicobar Project

Practice reading comprehension questions based on the editorial about the environmental and tribal concerns surrounding the Great Nicobar Project.

5 Questions Passing: 70%

Explore by Category

Editorial Categories

Politics and Governance 7 Economy 7 International Relations 2 Science and Technology 3 Environment 3 Society 0 Security 1 Infrastructure and Energy 2 Media and Communication 1 Miscellaneous 7

Vocabulary Feeds

Challenging Vocabulary 161 Idioms and Phrases 113 Phrasal Verbs 54

About Scoreclever

Your Complete Learning Ecosystem

Scoreclever helps you master Current Affairs, English Language, and General Awareness for all Banking, SSC, Railway, and Defence exams. The Scoreclever app has innovative learning techniques that make memorization and revision effortless.

Explore Scoreclever

Anything wrong in this content?

Give feedback

Request a feature?

Contact support

Looking to contribute?

Contact our team

Troubled waters: On the Great Nicobar Project

Reading Comprehension

Reading Comprehension - Great Nicobar Project

Explore by Category

Share this editorial

About Scoreclever

Anything wrong in this content?

Request a feature?

Looking to contribute?