Analysis of editorial from The Hindu newspaper on June 09, 2026
Strategic afterthought: On the Great Nicobar project
The government must be transparent with the Nicobar project
Great Nicobar ProjectEnvironmental ClearanceIndigenous TribesGalathea Bay PortPublic Investment Board
Sentences
Sentence 1 of 12
English Original
For a project so often invoked as a matter of national security strategy,the ballooning Great Nicobar Island development, now estimated to be at ₹91,000 crore,restson a remarkably thin strategic record.
For a project so often invoked as a matter of national security strategy
For a project that is repeatedly said to be important for the country’s protection and defense
SubjectWho/What
the ballooning Great Nicobar Island development, now estimated to be at ₹91,000 crore
The growing development project on Great Nicobar Island, which is now expected to cost 91,000 crore rupees
VerbWhat is happening
rests
Depends on or is based on
AdjunctAdditional info
on a remarkablythinstrategic record
On a very weak or small amount of evidence showing its security importance
Context and Background
Great Nicobar Project Scale and Rationale
The Great Nicobar Holistic Development Project is a massive initiative originally proposed at ₹75,000 crore, but now estimated at ₹91,000 crore. While the government cites its positioning near the Malacca Strait as key for national security and trade, critics argue the lack of written strategic plans shows security was used as an excuse to avoid environmental scrutiny.
Sentence 2 of 12
English Original
The Centrehas long citedthe “strategic” character of its centrepiece — a transshipment port at Galathea Bay —to withhold information on its environmental clearances.
Has been pointing to or referring to for a long time
ObjectWhat receives action
the “strategic” character of its centrepiece — a transshipment port at Galathea Bay —
The security-related importance of the main part of the project, which is a port at Galathea Bay where cargo is moved between ships
AdjunctAdditional info
to withhold information on its environmental clearances
To keep the public from seeing documents about the project’s impact on nature
Context and Background
Galathea Bay Environmental Clearances
Galathea Bay is a nesting ground for the giant leatherback turtle. The environment ministry granted clearances for the port in 2022, but because of the ‘strategic’ tag, the government refused to share the environmental impact assessment reports and the recommendations of the High-Powered Committee set up by the National Green Tribunal.
Sentence 3 of 12
English Original
Yet,the Public Investment Board (PIB), a Finance Ministry body,foundin August 2024that the port “lacked strategic objectives”.
the Public Investment Board (PIB), a Finance Ministry body
An official committee under the Ministry of Finance that checks if big government projects are worth spending money on
VerbWhat is happening
found
Discovered or concluded after studying the details
AdjunctAdditional info
in August 2024
During the eighth month of the year 2024
ObjectWhat receives action
that the port “lackedstrategic objectives”
That the proposed sea port did not have clear plans showing how it would help national security
Context and Background
Public Investment Board (PIB)
The PIB is a premier body under India’s Ministry of Finance. It examines and approves large public investment proposals by various ministries before they go to the Cabinet for final clearance. Its focus is on evaluating the economic viability and financial prudence of high-value government projects.
Sentence 4 of 12
English Original
That labelarrivedonly afterwards,from the Ministry of Defenceandseemsless like a founding rationale and more of an afterthought, retrofitted to a balance sheet.
Only after the initial planning and financial review were done
AdjunctAdditional info
from the Ministry of Defence
From the government department responsible for national security and military affairs
VerbWhat is happening
seems
Looks like or appears to be
ComplementCompletes meaning
less like a founding rationale and more of an afterthought, retrofitted to a balance sheet
Not like an original, logical reason for starting the project, but like a late excuse added to justify the cost
Context and Background
Ministry of Defence and the Strategic Tag
After the Finance Ministry’s PIB questioned the project’s strategic value in August 2024, the Ministry of Defence declared it strategically vital. This designation was subsequently used to bypass public consultations and withhold crucial environmental clearance details, drawing criticism that the security rationale was an afterthought.
Sentence 5 of 12
English Original
Both the PIB and the Public-Private Partnership Appraisal Committee (PPPAC)clearedthe proposal,yetthe PPPACrefused₹12,230 crore in Viability Gap Funding,telling the Ports Ministry to find the money within its own budget — an unusual rebuke for a venture sold as nationally vital.
Both the PIB and the Public-Private PartnershipAppraisal Committee (PPPAC)
Both the Public Investment Board and the committee that checks public-private partnership projects
VerbWhat is happening
cleared
Approved or gave permission to
ObjectWhat receives action
the proposal
The formal plan for the Great Nicobar project
SubjectWho/What
the PPPAC
The Public-Private Partnership Appraisal Committee
VerbWhat is happening
refused
Said no to providing the requested money
ObjectWhat receives action
₹12,230 crore in Viability Gap Funding
A grant of 12,230 crore rupees to make the project financially viable
AdjunctAdditional info
telling the Ports Ministry to find the money within its own budget — an unusual rebuke for a venture sold as nationally vital
Instructing the Ports Ministry to pay for it from their existing funds, which is a rare scolding for a project described as essential for the country
Context and Background
Viability Gap Funding (VGF) and PPPAC
The Public-Private Partnership Appraisal Committee (PPPAC) is India’s apex body under the Ministry of Finance for clearing PPP projects. Viability Gap Funding (VGF) is a government grant (usually up to 20% of the project cost) to support infrastructure projects that are socially and economically essential but financially unviable for private developers. Refusing VGF for a project indicates severe administrative and economic doubts about its returns.
Sentence 6 of 12
English Original
If the port cannot stand on commercial returns,andif its real purpose is military,the case for a commercial transshipment hubdissolves.
If the sea port cannot make enough money from shipping businesses to pay for itself
AdjunctAdditional info
if its real purpose is military
If the actual reason for building it is for army, navy, or defense use
SubjectWho/What
the case for a commercial transshipment hub
The argument or reason for building a business-focused shipping port
VerbWhat is happening
dissolves
Disappears or fails to have any strength
Sentence 7 of 12
English Original
Great Nicobarsitsat the southern tip of the Andaman and Nicobar archipelago,wrapped in tropical rainforest and ringed by reefs of rare ecological value.
The largest and southernmost island of the Nicobar group
VerbWhat is happening
sits
Is located or positioned
AdjunctAdditional info
at the southern tip of the Andaman and Nicobar archipelago
At the very bottom end of the group of islands that make up the Andaman and Nicobar chain
AdjunctAdditional info
wrapped in tropical rainforest and ringed by reefs of rare ecological value
Covered with dense wet forests and surrounded by coral reefs that are very important for nature’s balance
Context and Background
Ecology of Great Nicobar Island
Great Nicobar is the southernmost island of India, situated just 150 km north of Sumatra. It is home to the Great Nicobar Biosphere Reserve, which includes two national parks (Galathea and Campbell Bay). The island features unique biodiversity, including primary rainforests, coral reefs, nesting leatherback turtles, and endemic species like the Nicobar Megapode.
Sentence 8 of 12
English Original
The project — port, international airport, power plant and township —would clearvast tracts of that forest, much of it primary,anddisturbthe nesting beaches of the leatherback turtle and the habitat of the endemic Nicobar megapode.
The project — port, international airport, power plant and township —
The development plan which includes a port, airport, power station, and a new town
VerbWhat is happening
would clear
Would cut down or remove
ObjectWhat receives action
vast tracts of that forest, much of it primary
Huge areas of the island’s trees, most of which are original, untouched forests
VerbWhat is happening
disturb
Upset, harm, or damage
ObjectWhat receives action
the nesting beaches of the leatherback turtle and the habitat of the endemicNicobar megapode
The sandy shores where giant leatherback turtles lay eggs and the forest homes of the rare Nicobar megapode bird
Context and Background
Endemic Species of Great Nicobar
Great Nicobar Island is an ecological hotspot. The leatherback turtle (the world’s largest marine turtle) nests heavily at Galathea Bay. The Nicobar megapode is a unique, endangered bird that builds mounds of decaying vegetation to incubate its eggs. Because these species rely entirely on the island’s coastal forest and beaches, the mega-project threats their survival.
Sentence 9 of 12
English Original
Scientists who have studied the islandwarnthat the loss would be irreversible, and that no afforestation elsewhere can replace what is felled here.
Researchers and experts who have examined the environment of Great Nicobar Island
VerbWhat is happening
warn
Tell someone about a possible danger or problem in the future
ObjectWhat receives action
that the loss would be irreversible, and that no afforestation elsewhere can replace what is felled here
That the damage to nature cannot be undone, and planting trees in other places cannot replace the ancient trees cut down on this island
Context and Background
Compensatory Afforestation Controversy
Under Indian law (Forest Conservation Act), when forest land is diverted for non-forest use, compensatory afforestation must be undertaken. For Great Nicobar, the government planned compensatory afforestation in Haryana, thousands of kilometers away. Scientists argue that planting trees in a semi-arid zone cannot replace the lost biodiversity of a 130-million-year-old tropical evergreen rainforest.
Sentence 10 of 12
English Original
The island’s indigenous inhabitantshaveobjections of their own,running alongside the ecological ones but not reducible to them.
The native tribal people who have lived on the island for generations
VerbWhat is happening
have
Possess or hold
ObjectWhat receives action
objections of their own
Their own reasons for disagreeing with the project
AdjunctAdditional info
running alongside the ecological ones but not reducible to them
Existing at the same time as the nature-related worries, but representing separate human rights issues that cannot be simplified to just environment issues
Context and Background
Indigenous Tribes of Great Nicobar
Great Nicobar is home to two primary indigenous tribes: the Nicobarese (primarily agriculturists and fishers, resettled after the 2004 tsunami) and the Shompen (a Particularly Vulnerable Tribal Group or PVTG, who are semi-nomadic hunter-gatherers living in the interior forests). The project threatens their ancestral lands, resource access, and cultural survival.
Sentence 11 of 12
English Original
Local tribal councils, who initially supported the project,withdrewtheir consentin 2022when they realized they were being misled about the relocation of their ancestral villages.
Local tribal councils, who initially supported the project
The governing bodies of the local indigenous tribes, who at first agreed to the development plan
VerbWhat is happening
withdrew
Took back or cancelled
ObjectWhat receives action
their consent
Their official permission or agreement
AdjunctAdditional info
in 2022
During the year 2022
AdjunctAdditional info
when they realized they were being misled about the relocation of their ancestral villages
At the moment they understood that they were given false information about moving their families out of their traditional lands
Context and Background
Forest Rights Act and Tribal Consent
Under India’s Scheduled Tribes and Other Traditional Forest Dwellers (Recognition of Forest Rights) Act, 2006 (FRA), any diversion of forest land requires the free, prior, and informed consent of the local Gram Sabhas. In Great Nicobar, the tribal councils withdrew their consent in 2022, alleging that the administration obtained it by concealing that their villages would be taken over.
Sentence 12 of 12
English Original
Such a projectneeds to be builton consensus,not by steamrolling native concerns.
Not by forcefully ignoring or crushing the worries of the local tribal people
Sentence 1 of 12
Sentence 1 of 12
For a project so often invoked as a matter of national security strategy,the ballooning Great Nicobar Island development, now estimated to be at ₹91,000 crore,restson a remarkably thin strategic record.
Phrase Breakdown
Adjunct
For a project so often invoked as a matter of national security strategy
For a project that is repeatedly said to be important for the country’s protection and defense
Subject
the ballooning Great Nicobar Island development, now estimated to be at ₹91,000 crore
The growing development project on Great Nicobar Island, which is now expected to cost 91,000 crore rupees
Verb
rests
Depends on or is based on
Adjunct
on a remarkably thin strategic record
On a very weak or small amount of evidence showing its security importance
Sentence 2 of 12
The Centrehas long citedthe “strategic” character of its centrepiece — a transshipment port at Galathea Bay —to withhold information on its environmental clearances.
Phrase Breakdown
Subject
The Centre
The Union Government of India
Verb
has long cited
Has been pointing to or referring to for a long time
Object
the “strategic” character of its centrepiece — a transshipment port at Galathea Bay —
The security-related importance of the main part of the project, which is a port at Galathea Bay where cargo is moved between ships
Adjunct
to withhold information on its environmental clearances
To keep the public from seeing documents about the project’s impact on nature
Sentence 3 of 12
Yet,the Public Investment Board (PIB), a Finance Ministry body,foundin August 2024that the port “lacked strategic objectives”.
Phrase Breakdown
Adjunct
Yet
But; despite what was said before about security
Subject
the Public Investment Board (PIB), a Finance Ministry body
An official committee under the Ministry of Finance that checks if big government projects are worth spending money on
Verb
found
Discovered or concluded after studying the details
Adjunct
in August 2024
During the eighth month of the year 2024
Object
that the port “lacked strategic objectives”
That the proposed sea port did not have clear plans showing how it would help national security
Sentence 4 of 12
That labelarrivedonly afterwards,from the Ministry of Defenceandseemsless like a founding rationale and more of an afterthought, retrofitted to a balance sheet.
Phrase Breakdown
Subject
That label
The term ‘strategic’ used to describe the project
Verb
arrived
Came or was given
Adjunct
only afterwards
Only after the initial planning and financial review were done
Adjunct
from the Ministry of Defence
From the government department responsible for national security and military affairs
Verb
seems
Looks like or appears to be
Complement
less like a founding rationale and more of an afterthought, retrofitted to a balance sheet
Not like an original, logical reason for starting the project, but like a late excuse added to justify the cost
Sentence 5 of 12
Both the PIB and the Public-Private Partnership Appraisal Committee (PPPAC)clearedthe proposal,yetthe PPPACrefused₹12,230 crore in Viability Gap Funding,telling the Ports Ministry to find the money within its own budget — an unusual rebuke for a venture sold as nationally vital.
Phrase Breakdown
Subject
Both the PIB and the Public-Private Partnership Appraisal Committee (PPPAC)
Both the Public Investment Board and the committee that checks public-private partnership projects
Verb
cleared
Approved or gave permission to
Object
the proposal
The formal plan for the Great Nicobar project
Subject
the PPPAC
The Public-Private Partnership Appraisal Committee
Verb
refused
Said no to providing the requested money
Object
₹12,230 crore in Viability Gap Funding
A grant of 12,230 crore rupees to make the project financially viable
Adjunct
telling the Ports Ministry to find the money within its own budget — an unusual rebuke for a venture sold as nationally vital
Instructing the Ports Ministry to pay for it from their existing funds, which is a rare scolding for a project described as essential for the country
Sentence 6 of 12
If the port cannot stand on commercial returns,andif its real purpose is military,the case for a commercial transshipment hubdissolves.
Phrase Breakdown
Adjunct
If the port cannot stand on commercial returns
If the sea port cannot make enough money from shipping businesses to pay for itself
Adjunct
if its real purpose is military
If the actual reason for building it is for army, navy, or defense use
Subject
the case for a commercial transshipment hub
The argument or reason for building a business-focused shipping port
Verb
dissolves
Disappears or fails to have any strength
Sentence 7 of 12
Great Nicobarsitsat the southern tip of the Andaman and Nicobar archipelago,wrapped in tropical rainforest and ringed by reefs of rare ecological value.
Phrase Breakdown
Subject
Great Nicobar
The largest and southernmost island of the Nicobar group
Verb
sits
Is located or positioned
Adjunct
at the southern tip of the Andaman and Nicobar archipelago
At the very bottom end of the group of islands that make up the Andaman and Nicobar chain
Adjunct
wrapped in tropical rainforest and ringed by reefs of rare ecological value
Covered with dense wet forests and surrounded by coral reefs that are very important for nature’s balance
Sentence 8 of 12
The project — port, international airport, power plant and township —would clearvast tracts of that forest, much of it primary,anddisturbthe nesting beaches of the leatherback turtle and the habitat of the endemic Nicobar megapode.
Phrase Breakdown
Subject
The project — port, international airport, power plant and township —
The development plan which includes a port, airport, power station, and a new town
Verb
would clear
Would cut down or remove
Object
vast tracts of that forest, much of it primary
Huge areas of the island’s trees, most of which are original, untouched forests
Verb
disturb
Upset, harm, or damage
Object
the nesting beaches of the leatherback turtle and the habitat of the endemic Nicobar megapode
The sandy shores where giant leatherback turtles lay eggs and the forest homes of the rare Nicobar megapode bird
Sentence 9 of 12
Scientists who have studied the islandwarnthat the loss would be irreversible, and that no afforestation elsewhere can replace what is felled here.
Phrase Breakdown
Subject
Scientists who have studied the island
Researchers and experts who have examined the environment of Great Nicobar Island
Verb
warn
Tell someone about a possible danger or problem in the future
Object
that the loss would be irreversible, and that no afforestation elsewhere can replace what is felled here
That the damage to nature cannot be undone, and planting trees in other places cannot replace the ancient trees cut down on this island
Sentence 10 of 12
The island’s indigenous inhabitantshaveobjections of their own,running alongside the ecological ones but not reducible to them.
Phrase Breakdown
Subject
The island’s indigenous inhabitants
The native tribal people who have lived on the island for generations
Verb
have
Possess or hold
Object
objections of their own
Their own reasons for disagreeing with the project
Adjunct
running alongside the ecological ones but not reducible to them
Existing at the same time as the nature-related worries, but representing separate human rights issues that cannot be simplified to just environment issues
Sentence 11 of 12
Local tribal councils, who initially supported the project,withdrewtheir consentin 2022when they realized they were being misled about the relocation of their ancestral villages.
Phrase Breakdown
Subject
Local tribal councils, who initially supported the project
The governing bodies of the local indigenous tribes, who at first agreed to the development plan
Verb
withdrew
Took back or cancelled
Object
their consent
Their official permission or agreement
Adjunct
in 2022
During the year 2022
Adjunct
when they realized they were being misled about the relocation of their ancestral villages
At the moment they understood that they were given false information about moving their families out of their traditional lands
Sentence 12 of 12
Such a projectneeds to be builton consensus,not by steamrolling native concerns.
Phrase Breakdown
Subject
Such a project
A huge development plan of this kind
Verb
needs to be built
Must be constructed or established
Adjunct
on consensus
Based on agreement among everyone involved
Adjunct
not by steamrolling native concerns
Not by forcefully ignoring or crushing the worries of the local tribal people
Reading Comprehension
Practice questions based on this editorial
Reading Comprehension - Strategic Afterthought
Practice reading comprehension questions based on the editorial examining the Great Nicobar development project, its financial justifications, environmental hazards, and tribal consent.
Scoreclever helps you master Current Affairs, English Language, and General Awareness for all Banking, SSC, Railway, and Defence exams. The Scoreclever app has innovative learning techniques that make memorization and revision effortless.