The Hindu Editorial • June 01, 2026 • Read Original

Language decorum: On the three-language formula in CBSE schools

School education should not be the site of a cultural battle

Scoreclever

Win Exams Cleverly

The Hindu Read Original

15 min read

Analysis of editorial from The Hindu newspaper on June 01, 2026

Language decorum: On the three-language formula in CBSE schools

School education should not be the site of a cultural battle

Three-Language FormulaCBSE SchoolsSupreme CourtNEP 2020National Curriculum Framework 2023Language Imposition

Sentences

Sentence 1 of 17

English Original

The Supreme Court of India has issued notices to the Union Government, the CBSE, and the NCERT, directing them to file a comprehensive report on their logistical preparedness to implement a three-language formula in all CBSE schools for Class 9 students from July 1, 2026.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

The of India

The highest court of law in India.

Part 2

has

Has officially sent or announced.

Part 3

Official written announcements or legal orders asking for responses.

Part 4

to the , the CBSE, and the NCERT

To India’s central government and the primary educational boards and councils.

Part 5

directing them to file a report on their to implement a in all CBSE schools for Class 9 students from July 1, 2026

Ordering them to submit a complete report about their practical readiness, including teachers and textbooks, to start the three-language rule for ninth-grade students by July 1, 2026.

Context and Background

The Three-Language Formula and CBSE

The Three-Language Formula was first proposed by the Central Advisory Board of Education (CABE) in 1956 and incorporated into the National Education Policy (NEP) in 1968. It aims to promote multilingualism by requiring students to study three languages, typically English, Hindi, and a regional language. In May 2026, the CBSE mandated this formula for Class 9 students from July 1, 2026, sparking legal challenges over logistical preparedness and language imposition.

Sentence 2 of 17

English Original

On May 27, while hearing petitioners challenging the CBSE move, the Court declined to grant an immediate stay on the policy but acknowledged that concerns over “hardship and inconvenience” warranted review.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

On May 27, while hearing challenging the CBSE move

On May 27, when the judges were listening to the arguments of those who filed cases against the new CBSE language rule.

Part 2

the Court

The Supreme Court of India.

Part 3

Refused or chose not to do something.

Part 4

to grant an immediate on the policy

To stop the enforcement of the language rule immediately.

Part 5

Accepted or admitted that something is true.

Part 6

that concerns over “ and inconvenience” review

That the worries about difficulties and trouble for students and teachers justify a second look.

Sentence 3 of 17

English Original

The Court will hear arguments on July 15 and 16.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

The Court

The Supreme Court of India.

Part 2

will hear

Will listen to and examine in detail.

Part 3

The points of view and reasons presented by the lawyers of both sides.

Part 4

on July 15 and 16

On the scheduled dates of July 15 and July 16, 2026.

Sentence 4 of 17

English Original

The casual manner in which the government is using the CBSE to enforce its contentious language policy once again shows complete disregard for students, teachers, and parents.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

The in which the government is using the CBSE to its language policy

The careless way in which the ruling government is utilizing the central school board (CBSE) to make schools follow its disputed language rules.

Part 2

once again

Another time; repeating a previous occurrence.

Part 3

shows

Demonstrates, reveals, or makes visible.

Part 4

complete for students, teachers, and parents

Total lack of attention, care, or concern for school kids, their teachers, and their mothers and fathers.

Sentence 5 of 17

English Original

On May 15, the CBSE had issued a circular mandating the study of three languages for Class 9 students from July 1, citing alignment with the NEP 2020 and the National Curriculum Framework for School Education 2023.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

On May 15

On May 15, 2026.

Part 2

the

The Central Board of Secondary Education, the national board governing secondary school education in India.

Part 3

had issued

Had officially published and distributed.

Part 4

a the study of three languages for Class 9 students from July 1

An official letter or notification making it compulsory for ninth-grade students to learn three different languages starting from July 1, 2026.

Part 5

with the and the

Pointing out that this new rule is based on and matches the targets of the National Education Policy of 2020 and the school course framework of 2023.

Sentence 6 of 17

English Original

At least two of the three must be native Indian languages.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

At least two of the three

A minimum of two languages out of the three required ones.

Part 2

must be

Are required to be.

Part 3

Indian languages

Languages that originated in the Indian subcontinent (such as Hindi, Sanskrit, Tamil, Kannada, Marathi, etc.).

Sentence 7 of 17

English Original

Foreign languages such as French or German could only be taken as a third language if the first two were Indian, or alternatively as an optional fourth subject.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

such as French or German

Languages from other countries, such as French or German.

Part 2

could only be taken

Were permitted to be selected only under certain conditions.

Part 3

as a third language

As the third subject in the language requirements list.

Part 4

if the first two were Indian

Only on the condition that the primary two languages studied were native Indian languages.

Part 5

as an fourth subject

Or, as another choice, as an extra subject that does not affect the compulsory language count.

Sentence 8 of 17

English Original

In a meagre effort to camouflage the hardship unleashed on the students, the CBSE exempted the third language from the Class 10 Board examination, which would instead be assessed through school-based internal evaluations, though the marks would still appear on the final certificate.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

In a effort to the hardship on the students

In a very small and weak attempt to hide the difficulties and stress forced onto the students.

Part 2

the CBSE

The Central Board of Secondary Education.

Part 3

Released or freed from an obligation or exam requirement.

Part 4

the third language

The newly mandated third language subject.

Part 5

from the Class 10 Board examination

From the final nation-wide examination taken at the end of the tenth grade.

Part 6

which would instead be through school-based

Which, rather than a board exam, would be tested and graded inside the student’s own school by their own teachers.

Part 7

though the marks would still appear on the final certificate

Even though the scores or grades obtained in this subject will still be printed on the final graduation report card.

Sentence 9 of 17

English Original

Barely weeks earlier, the CBSE had stated that the third-language requirement would be deferred until the 2029-30 academic year.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

Barely weeks earlier

Just a very short time (only a few weeks) before this new announcement.

Part 2

the CBSE

The Central Board of Secondary Education.

Part 3

had stated

Had officially declared or put in writing.

Part 4

that the third-language requirement would be until the 2029-30

That the compulsory rule to learn a third language was going to be postponed to the school session of 2029-2030.

Sentence 10 of 17

English Original

The abrupt turnabout can only be explained as a political decision.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

The

The sudden, unexpected reversal of policy or plan.

Part 2

can only be explained

Has no other reason or interpretation possible.

Part 3

as a

As a choice made to satisfy political goals rather than educational needs.

Sentence 11 of 17

English Original

The move is being challenged in the Court on multiple grounds, including constitutional ones.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

The move

The policy decision or action taken by CBSE.

Part 2

is being

Is being formally questioned, opposed, or disputed.

Part 3

in the Court

In the Supreme Court of India.

Part 4

on , including

For several different reasons, including arguments that the policy violates the Indian Constitution.

Sentence 12 of 17

English Original

The petitioners argue that language is a matter of personal choice and cannot be imposed by the state.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

The petitioners

The parents, teachers, or groups who filed the lawsuit challenging the policy.

Part 2

argue

Present arguments or state their reasons in support of their case.

Part 3

that language is a matter of and cannot be by the

That deciding what languages to learn is an individual’s private right, and the government does not have the power to force it on them.

Sentence 13 of 17

English Original

It is also being pointed out that the NEP 2020, in whose name the mandate is being enforced, promises flexibility and guarantees that no language shall be imposed on any student or State.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

This fact (dummy subject representing the following statement).

Part 2

is also being

Is also being highlighted or brought to attention.

Part 3

that the NEP 2020, in whose name the is being , promises and that no language on any student or State

That the education policy of 2020, which is being used to justify this new rule, actually pledges flexibility and promises that no language will be forced on any child or regional state.

Context and Background

NEP 2020 and Language Flexibility

The National Education Policy (NEP) 2020 emphasizes the promotion of multilingualism and national unity. However, it explicitly states that the three-language formula must be implemented with flexibility. It guarantees that no language will be imposed on any student or State, aiming to prevent regional friction, particularly in non-Hindi speaking states like Tamil Nadu.

Sentence 14 of 17

English Original

The petitioners also argue that the CBSE, as an executive body, lacks the authority to impose such a sweeping educational mandate without backing from parliamentary legislation, regardless of what the NEP says, being an executive policy intent and not a statute.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

The petitioners

The parents, teachers, and school representatives challenging the rule in court.

Part 2

also

In addition.

Part 3

argue

Make a legal case or present reasons.

Part 4

that the CBSE, as an , lacks the to impose such a without backing from , regardless of what the NEP says, being an executive and not a

That since the CBSE is just a government board and not a law-making body, it does not have the legal power to make such a big mandatory change in schools unless the Parliament passes a law. The NEP is just a policy guideline and not an actual law.

Context and Background

Executive Policies vs. Statutes

In Indian governance, an Executive Policy (such as the NEP 2020) represents the government’s guiding vision and intention but is not legally binding. A Statute (or legislation), on the other hand, is a formal law passed by Parliament or state legislatures. An executive body like the CBSE can implement guidelines, but sweeping mandates that impact fundamental rights or impose heavy burdens typically require statutory backing.

Sentence 15 of 17

English Original

Parents and teachers are alarmed about the added pressure on students just before their Board examinations.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

Parents and teachers

The students’ mothers, fathers, and school educators.

Part 2

are

Are worried, anxious, or distressed.

Part 3

about the on students just before their

Concerning the extra workload and stress placed on school kids right before they take their final board exams.

Sentence 16 of 17

English Original

School administrators have flagged a shortage of trained language teachers and the unavailability of appropriate textbooks.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

School

People responsible for managing, directing, and running schools.

Part 2

have

Have pointed out, highlighted, or drawn attention to as a problem.

Part 3

a of trained language teachers and the of textbooks

A lack of qualified instructors to teach the languages, and the fact that correct educational books are not available to buy or use.

Sentence 17 of 17

English Original

Turning school education into a cultural battleground is not helping India’s ambition to become a global reservoir of advanced human resources.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

Turning school education into a

Making children’s schooling a place where adults fight over regional language and cultural politics.

Part 2

is not helping

Does not support or benefit.

Part 3

India’s to become a global of

The national dream of India to be a major worldwide supplier of highly skilled, well-educated, and advanced professionals.

Sentence 1 of 17

Sentences Breakdown

Editorial Summary

5-Point Summary

1 The Supreme Court of India issued notices to the Centre, CBSE, and NCERT to report on their preparedness to implement the three-language formula in all CBSE schools for Class 9 from July 1, 2026.
2 While the Court did not immediately halt the policy, it acknowledged the challenges and set the next hearings for July 15 and 16, 2026.
3 The CBSE circular mandates studying three languages for Class 9, requiring at least two of them to be native Indian languages, with foreign languages relegated to a third or optional fourth subject.
4 Petitioners challenge the policy on multiple grounds, arguing that language is a personal choice, the mandate contradicts the flexibility promised in NEP 2020, and the CBSE lacks legislative authority.
5 School administrators, parents, and teachers face severe pressure due to a shortage of trained language teachers, lack of textbooks, and the turnabout from CBSE’s earlier plan to defer the policy to 2029-30.

Tone of the Editorial

Critical

Why this tone?

The editorial is highly critical of the government and CBSE’s hasty and politically motivated implementation of the three-language formula. It accuses the government of showing complete disregard for students and teachers, calls CBSE’s attempts to ease the burden a ‘meagre effort to camouflage the hardship’, and warns against turning school education into a cultural battleground.

Sentence 1 of 17

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

The Supreme Court of India

The highest court of law in India.

Part 2

has issued

Has officially sent or announced.

Part 3

notices

Official written announcements or legal orders asking for responses.

Part 4

to the Union Government, the CBSE, and the NCERT

To India’s central government and the primary educational boards and councils.

Part 5

directing them to file a comprehensive report on their logistical preparedness to implement a three-language formula in all CBSE schools for Class 9 students from July 1, 2026

Ordering them to submit a complete report about their practical readiness, including teachers and textbooks, to start the three-language rule for ninth-grade students by July 1, 2026.

Sentence 2 of 17

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

On May 27, while hearing petitioners challenging the CBSE move

On May 27, when the judges were listening to the arguments of those who filed cases against the new CBSE language rule.

Part 2

the Court

The Supreme Court of India.

Part 3

declined

Refused or chose not to do something.

Part 4

to grant an immediate stay on the policy

To stop the enforcement of the language rule immediately.

Part 5

acknowledged

Accepted or admitted that something is true.

Part 6

that concerns over “hardship and inconvenience” warranted review

That the worries about difficulties and trouble for students and teachers justify a second look.

Sentence 3 of 17

The Court will hear arguments on July 15 and 16.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

The Court

The Supreme Court of India.

Part 2

will hear

Will listen to and examine in detail.

Part 3

arguments

The points of view and reasons presented by the lawyers of both sides.

Part 4

on July 15 and 16

On the scheduled dates of July 15 and July 16, 2026.

Sentence 4 of 17

The casual manner in which the government is using the CBSE to enforce its contentious language policy once again shows complete disregard for students, teachers, and parents.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

The casual manner in which the government is using the CBSE to enforce its contentious language policy

The careless way in which the ruling government is utilizing the central school board (CBSE) to make schools follow its disputed language rules.

Part 2

once again

Another time; repeating a previous occurrence.

Part 3

shows

Demonstrates, reveals, or makes visible.

Part 4

complete disregard for students, teachers, and parents

Total lack of attention, care, or concern for school kids, their teachers, and their mothers and fathers.

Sentence 5 of 17

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

On May 15

On May 15, 2026.

Part 2

the CBSE

The Central Board of Secondary Education, the national board governing secondary school education in India.

Part 3

had issued

Had officially published and distributed.

Part 4

a circular mandating the study of three languages for Class 9 students from July 1

An official letter or notification making it compulsory for ninth-grade students to learn three different languages starting from July 1, 2026.

Part 5

citing alignment with the NEP 2020 and the National Curriculum Framework for School Education 2023

Pointing out that this new rule is based on and matches the targets of the National Education Policy of 2020 and the school course framework of 2023.

Sentence 6 of 17

At least two of the three must be native Indian languages.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

At least two of the three

A minimum of two languages out of the three required ones.

Part 2

must be

Are required to be.

Part 3

native Indian languages

Languages that originated in the Indian subcontinent (such as Hindi, Sanskrit, Tamil, Kannada, Marathi, etc.).

Sentence 7 of 17

Foreign languages such as French or German could only be taken as a third language if the first two were Indian, or alternatively as an optional fourth subject.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

Foreign languages such as French or German

Languages from other countries, such as French or German.

Part 2

could only be taken

Were permitted to be selected only under certain conditions.

Part 3

as a third language

As the third subject in the language requirements list.

Part 4

if the first two were Indian

Only on the condition that the primary two languages studied were native Indian languages.

Part 5

alternatively as an optional fourth subject

Or, as another choice, as an extra subject that does not affect the compulsory language count.

Sentence 8 of 17

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

In a meagre effort to camouflage the hardship unleashed on the students

In a very small and weak attempt to hide the difficulties and stress forced onto the students.

Part 2

the CBSE

The Central Board of Secondary Education.

Part 3

exempted

Released or freed from an obligation or exam requirement.

Part 4

the third language

The newly mandated third language subject.

Part 5

from the Class 10 Board examination

From the final nation-wide examination taken at the end of the tenth grade.

Part 6

which would instead be assessed through school-based internal evaluations

Which, rather than a board exam, would be tested and graded inside the student’s own school by their own teachers.

Part 7

though the marks would still appear on the final certificate

Even though the scores or grades obtained in this subject will still be printed on the final graduation report card.

Sentence 9 of 17

Barely weeks earlier, the CBSE had stated that the third-language requirement would be deferred until the 2029-30 academic year.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

Barely weeks earlier

Just a very short time (only a few weeks) before this new announcement.

Part 2

the CBSE

The Central Board of Secondary Education.

Part 3

had stated

Had officially declared or put in writing.

Part 4

that the third-language requirement would be deferred until the 2029-30 academic year

That the compulsory rule to learn a third language was going to be postponed to the school session of 2029-2030.

Sentence 10 of 17

The abrupt turnabout can only be explained as a political decision.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

The abrupt turnabout

The sudden, unexpected reversal of policy or plan.

Part 2

can only be explained

Has no other reason or interpretation possible.

Part 3

as a political decision

As a choice made to satisfy political goals rather than educational needs.

Sentence 11 of 17

The move is being challenged in the Court on multiple grounds, including constitutional ones.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

The move

The policy decision or action taken by CBSE.

Part 2

is being challenged

Is being formally questioned, opposed, or disputed.

Part 3

in the Court

In the Supreme Court of India.

Part 4

on multiple grounds, including constitutional ones

For several different reasons, including arguments that the policy violates the Indian Constitution.

Sentence 12 of 17

The petitioners argue that language is a matter of personal choice and cannot be imposed by the state.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

The petitioners

The parents, teachers, or groups who filed the lawsuit challenging the policy.

Part 2

argue

Present arguments or state their reasons in support of their case.

Part 3

that language is a matter of personal choice and cannot be imposed by the state

That deciding what languages to learn is an individual’s private right, and the government does not have the power to force it on them.

Sentence 13 of 17

It is also being pointed out that the NEP 2020, in whose name the mandate is being enforced, promises flexibility and guarantees that no language shall be imposed on any student or State.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

This fact (dummy subject representing the following statement).

Part 2

is also being pointed out

Is also being highlighted or brought to attention.

Part 3

that the NEP 2020, in whose name the mandate is being enforced, promises flexibility and guarantees that no language shall be imposed on any student or State

That the education policy of 2020, which is being used to justify this new rule, actually pledges flexibility and promises that no language will be forced on any child or regional state.

Sentence 14 of 17

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

The petitioners

The parents, teachers, and school representatives challenging the rule in court.

Part 2

also

In addition.

Part 3

argue

Make a legal case or present reasons.

Part 4

that the CBSE, as an executive body, lacks the authority to impose such a sweeping educational mandate without backing from parliamentary legislation, regardless of what the NEP says, being an executive policy intent and not a statute

Sentence 15 of 17

Parents and teachers are alarmed about the added pressure on students just before their Board examinations.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

Parents and teachers

The students’ mothers, fathers, and school educators.

Part 2

are alarmed

Are worried, anxious, or distressed.

Part 3

about the added pressure on students just before their Board examinations

Concerning the extra workload and stress placed on school kids right before they take their final board exams.

Sentence 16 of 17

School administrators have flagged a shortage of trained language teachers and the unavailability of appropriate textbooks.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

School administrators

People responsible for managing, directing, and running schools.

Part 2

have flagged

Have pointed out, highlighted, or drawn attention to as a problem.

Part 3

a shortage of trained language teachers and the unavailability of appropriate textbooks

A lack of qualified instructors to teach the languages, and the fact that correct educational books are not available to buy or use.

Sentence 17 of 17

Turning school education into a cultural battleground is not helping India’s ambition to become a global reservoir of advanced human resources.

Sentence Breakdown

Part 1

Turning school education into a cultural battleground

Making children’s schooling a place where adults fight over regional language and cultural politics.

Part 2

is not helping

Does not support or benefit.

Part 3

India’s ambition to become a global reservoir of advanced human resources

The national dream of India to be a major worldwide supplier of highly skilled, well-educated, and advanced professionals.

Reading Comprehension

Practice questions based on this editorial

Reading Comprehension - Three-Language Formula

Practice reading comprehension questions based on the editorial about the three-language formula in CBSE schools.

5 Questions Passing: 70%

Explore by Category

Editorial Categories

Politics and Governance 7 Economy 5 International Relations 2 Science and Technology 2 Environment 2 Society 0 Security 1 Infrastructure and Energy 2 Media and Communication 1 Miscellaneous 6

Vocabulary Feeds

Challenging Vocabulary 135 Idioms and Phrases 90 Phrasal Verbs 44

About Scoreclever

Your Complete Learning Ecosystem

Scoreclever helps you master Current Affairs, English Language, and General Awareness for all Banking, SSC, Railway, and Defence exams. The Scoreclever app has innovative learning techniques that make memorization and revision effortless.

Explore Scoreclever

Anything wrong in this content?

Give feedback

Request a feature?

Contact support

Looking to contribute?

Contact our team

Language decorum: On the three-language formula in CBSE schools

Reading Comprehension

Reading Comprehension - Three-Language Formula

Explore by Category

Share this editorial

About Scoreclever

Anything wrong in this content?

Request a feature?

Looking to contribute?