Analysis of editorial from The Hindu newspaper on January 30, 2026
Devolution, not debt: On the rapid expansion of State Development Loans
Cesses and surcharges levied by Centre must be in divisible pool
Tax DevolutionState Development LoansFiscal FederalismGST15th Finance CommissionDivisible PoolCentre-State Relations
Sentences
Sentence 1 of 18
English Original
While the Union Budget is keenly tracked by States to assess their share in overall Central tax devolution,itis becomingincreasingly clear that this revenue stream no longer plays the stabilising role it once did in State finances.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
While the is by States to assess their share in overall Central tax
Even though States watch the Central government’s budget very carefully to see how much tax money they will get back
Part 2
it
The situation (this is a placeholder for the idea that follows)
Part 3
is becoming
Is starting to be (shows a process happening right now)
Part 4
increasingly clear that this no longer plays the it once did in State finances
More and more obvious that this tax money from the Centre is not enough to keep State money matters steady like it used to
Context and Background
Central Tax Devolution
In India, the Central Government collects most of the major taxes (like Income Tax and Corporation Tax). According to Article 280 of the Constitution, a Finance Commission is appointed every five years to decide how much of this tax money should be shared with the State Governments. Currently, the 15th Finance Commission has recommended that 41% of the central pool of taxes be given to the States.
Sentence 2 of 18
English Original
The evidenceliesin the rapid expansion of State Development Loans (SDLs), which have emerged as a key financing instrument for States’ day-to-day spending needs.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
The evidence
The proof or the facts that show something is true
Part 2
lies
Can be found or exists (in something)
Part 3
in the of , which have emerged as a key for States’
In the fast growth of money that States borrow from the market, which has become a main way for them to pay for their regular daily expenses
Context and Background
What are SDLs?
State Development Loans (SDLs) are debt securities issued by State Governments to manage their budget deficits. They are similar to Central Government Dated Securities but are issued by States. States borrow this money from the open market (banks, insurance companies) through auctions conducted by the Reserve Bank of India (RBI).
Sentence 3 of 18
English Original
In 2024-25 (Revised Estimates),SDLsamountedto about 35% of Tamil Nadu’s total revenue receipts and nearly 26% of Maharashtra’s—levels that would have been considered fiscally exceptional a decade ago.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
In 2024-25 ()
In the financial year 2024-2025, according to the updated calculations
Part 2
SDLs
State Development Loans (money borrowed by states)
Part 3
amounted
Reached the total value of or was equal to
Part 4
to about 35% of Tamil Nadu’s total and nearly 26% of Maharashtra’s
To nearly one-third of all the money Tamil Nadu earned and about one-fourth of Maharashtra’s total earnings
Part 5
levels that would have been considered a ago
Amounts that would have been seen as very unusual or very high ten years ago
Context and Background
Revised Estimates (RE)
When a government presents its budget, it gives ‘Budget Estimates’ (projections). Later, mid-year, it provides ‘Revised Estimates’ (RE) based on actual income and spending so far. RE is considered a more realistic reflection of the state’s financial health than the initial budget plan.
Sentence 4 of 18
English Original
This shiftgatheredpaceafter 2020-21, when the COVID-19 pandemic delivered a severe economic shock and Central devolution proved inadequate.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
This shift
This change (referring to the increase in borrowing)
Part 2
gathered
Started to get more or collected (in this context, it means increased)
Part 3
pace
Speed (meaning the change happened faster)
Part 4
after 2020-21, when the COVID-19 pandemic delivered a severe and Central devolution
After the 2020-21 year, when the COVID-19 virus badly hurt the economy and the tax money from the Centre was not enough
Context and Background
Impact of COVID-19 on State Finances
The 2020-21 pandemic led to national lockdowns which stopped most economic activities, reducing tax collections for both Centre and States. At the same time, States had to spend huge amounts on healthcare and relief. Since the Centre’s own collections were low, the amount of money it could share (devolution) with States also decreased significantly.
Sentence 5 of 18
English Original
This dependence on borrowinghas not reversedsince.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
This on borrowing
The need to keep taking loans to manage expenses
Part 2
has not
Has not changed back to how it was before
Part 3
since
From that time until now
Sentence 6 of 18
English Original
Instead,Statesare increasingly relyingon SDLs;borrowings by profit-making State PSUs and Special Purpose Vehiclesare doneto finance even routine revenue expenditure.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
Instead
Rather than the situation getting better
Part 2
States
State governments in India
Part 3
are increasingly relying
Are using more and more (as their main source)
Part 4
on SDLs
On market loans (State Development Loans)
Part 5
borrowings by profit-making and
Loans taken by government-owned companies (that make money) and special groups set up for specific projects
Part 6
are done
Are being carried out or performed
Part 7
to finance even
To pay for even regular, daily costs like salaries or repairs which should usually be paid from tax money
Context and Background
Off-Budget Borrowing
When a government borrows money directly, it shows up in its budget deficit. However, sometimes governments ask their companies (PSUs) or special organizations (SPVs) to borrow money on their behalf. This is called ‘off-budget borrowing’. The Centre has recently started including such borrowings in the State’s total debt limit to ensure more transparency.
Sentence 7 of 18
English Original
Thishas happeneddespite the 15th Finance Commission fixing States’ share at 41% of the divisible pool,as the effective flow of resources has been eroded by the growing use of cesses and surcharges, which lie outside the divisible pool.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
This
This situation (increased borrowing by States)
Part 2
has happened
Has taken place or occurred
Part 3
despite the fixing States’ share at 41% of the
Even though the 15th Finance Commission said that States should get 41% of the shared tax money
Part 4
as the of resources has been by the growing use of , which lie outside the divisible pool
Because the actual money going to States has decreased because the Centre is using more special taxes (cesses and surcharges) that it doesn’t have to share
Context and Background
The Divisible Pool Conflict
The ‘Divisible Pool’ consists of all taxes except cesses and surcharges. In recent years, the Centre has increased the proportion of revenue it collects through cesses (like the GST Compensation Cess or Health and Education Cess). Since these are not part of the divisible pool, the ‘effective’ share States receive is often much lower than the 41% recommended by the Finance Commission.
Sentence 8 of 18
English Original
The problemisacute for industrialised States with a large indirect tax base.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
The problem
The issue of not getting enough shared tax money
Part 2
is
Is currently (describes the state of the problem)
Part 3
for with a large
Very serious or severe for States that have many factories and businesses that pay a lot of GST
Sentence 9 of 18
English Original
Since the introduction of GST in 2017,a substantial share of these revenuesis collectedby the Centreandredistributedthrough a formula that often weakens the fiscal link between tax effort and reward.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
Since the introduction of in 2017
Starting from when the Goods and Services Tax was started in 2017
Part 2
a of these revenues
A large part of this tax money
Part 3
is collected
Is gathered or taken (by the government)
Part 4
by the Centre
By the Central Government
Part 5
redistributed
Shared out or given back again in a different way
Part 6
through a formula that often weakens the between
Using a math rule that often makes the connection between how much tax a State collects and how much it gets back weaker
Context and Background
The GST Change
Before GST, States had more power to collect their own indirect taxes (like VAT). GST is a ‘destination-based’ tax, meaning revenue goes to the State where the goods are consumed, not where they are manufactured. This often hurts industrialised States (producers) while benefiting States with large populations (consumers).
Sentence 10 of 18
English Original
Consequently,welfare commitments — pensions for the elderly and retired employees and mass health insurance schemes for the poor —are increasingly being fundedthrough domestic borrowing.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
Consequently
As a result of this situation
Part 2
— pensions for the elderly and retired employees and for the poor —
Government promises to help people, like giving monthly money to old people and former workers, and providing free health insurance for poor people
Part 3
are increasingly being funded
Are being paid for more and more (with a certain source of money)
Part 4
through
By taking loans from within our own country (like from local banks)
Sentence 11 of 18
English Original
Thislimitsthe availability of funds for public capital expenditure and private investment, which is essential to sustain growth.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
This
This habit of using borrowed money for daily welfare expenses
Part 2
limits
Reduces or puts a stop to
Part 3
the for and , which is essential to
The amount of money left for building roads and bridges (public assets) and for private businesses to start new projects, which is needed to keep the country growing
Context and Background
Capex vs Revex
Governments spend money in two ways: Revenue Expenditure (paying salaries, interest, and welfare - consumed immediately) and Capital Expenditure (Capex - building infrastructure). If too much borrowed money is used for revenue expenditure, less is available for Capex, which is harmful because only Capex leads to long-term economic growth and jobs.
Sentence 12 of 18
English Original
A comparison of borrowing patterns over the past five years across Punjab, Uttar Pradesh, Tamil Nadu, Maharashtra and West Bengalunderlinesthis trend.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
A comparison of over the past five years across Punjab, Uttar Pradesh, Tamil Nadu, Maharashtra and West Bengal
Looking at how Punjab, Uttar Pradesh, Tamil Nadu, Maharashtra, and West Bengal have borrowed money over the last five years and comparing them
Part 2
underlines
Highlights or makes very clear
Part 3
this
This general direction or pattern (of increasing debt)
Sentence 13 of 18
English Original
West Bengal,which is structurally dependent on Central devolution — averaging about 47.7% of its revenue receipts over the last five years —continued to borrowheavily from the domestic market.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
West Bengal
The state of West Bengal
Part 2
which is on — averaging about 47.7% of its over the last five years —
Which naturally relies on the shared tax money from the Centre (getting nearly half of its total income from the Centre on average for five years)
Part 3
continued to borrow
Kept on taking loans consistently
Part 4
heavily from the domestic market
Large amounts of money from the local financial market (banks, etc.)
Sentence 14 of 18
English Original
SDLsconstitutedroughly 35% of the State’s revenueson average during this period, even as nominal tax devolution rose.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
State Development Loans (borrowed money)
Part 2
constituted
Made up or was equal to
Part 3
roughly 35% of the State’s revenues
About one-third of the total money West Bengal earned
Part 4
on average during this period, even as rose
During these five years, even though the actual number amount of tax money from the Centre went up
Sentence 15 of 18
English Original
Thispointsto a steady erosion of States’ fiscal autonomy, with potentially serious macroeconomic consequences as debt-to-GSDP ratios rise while assured revenue streams weaken.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
This
This data and trend of increasing borrowing
Part 2
points
Indicates or shows (towards a certain result)
Part 3
to a of States’ , with potentially serious as rise while weaken
To a slow loss of the State’s power to manage its own money, which could hurt the whole economy as their debt becomes too high compared to their income, while their guaranteed income gets smaller
Context and Background
What is GSDP?
GSDP stands for Gross State Domestic Product. It is the total value of all finished goods and services produced within a State in a specific period. Economists use the ‘Debt-to-GSDP’ ratio to check if a State’s debt is under control; if debt grows much faster than GSDP, the state may struggle to pay it back.
Sentence 16 of 18
English Original
If debt, rather than devolution, becomes the primary shock absorber in India’s federal system,fiscal sustainability itselfcomesunder strain.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
If debt, rather than devolution, becomes the primary in India’s
If taking loans, instead of getting shared tax money, becomes the main way to handle problems in India’s system of Centre and States
Part 2
itself
The very ability of the government to manage its money without failing in the future
Part 3
comes
Gets or enters a certain state
Part 4
Under pressure or difficulty
Sentence 17 of 18
English Original
Indianeedshigher effective devolution, and a reworking of horizontal devolution criteria to give greater weight to tax effort and efficiency.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
India
The country and its government system
Part 2
needs
Requires or must have (to improve something)
Part 3
higher , and a of to give greater weight to
More actual tax money shared with States, and a change in the rules used to decide how much each State gets, so that States which collect taxes efficiently get more reward
Context and Background
Horizontal Devolution
Sharing of taxes happens in two steps: ‘Vertical Devolution’ (Centre to States) and ‘Horizontal Devolution’ (dividing that amount among individual States). The Finance Commission uses criteria like population, area, forest cover, and ‘Income Distance’. States that collect taxes better argue they should get more (‘Tax Effort’), while poorer states need more support.
Sentence 18 of 18
English Original
Cesses and surchargesmust be broughtinto the divisible pool.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
and
Special taxes that the Centre usually keeps for itself
Part 2
must be brought
Should be included or added (as a rule)
Part 3
into the
Into the group of taxes that must be shared with the States
Sentence 1 of 18
Sentences Breakdown
Editorial Summary
5-Point Summary
1Indian States are increasingly relying on State Development Loans (SDLs) as Central tax devolution fails to stabilize their finances.
2Borrowing has reached high levels in states like Tamil Nadu and Maharashtra, shifting from a pandemic shock to a permanent financing method.
3The 15th Finance Commission set the States’ share at 41%, but the use of cesses and surcharges by the Centre reduces the actual money shared.
4GST introduction and current redistribution formulas have weakened the link between a state’s tax contribution and the reward it receives.
5To ensure fiscal sustainability, India needs higher effective devolution and must include cesses and surcharges in the divisible pool.
Tone of the Editorial
Analytical
Why this tone?
The editorial provides a detailed examination of India’s fiscal federalism, using data from specific states like West Bengal and Tamil Nadu to explain the shift from revenue sharing to debt. It objectively identifies structural problems like cesses, surcharges, and GST formulas while offering specific policy recommendations for reform.
Sentence 1 of 18
While the Union Budget is keenly tracked by States to assess their share in overall Central tax devolution,itis becomingincreasingly clear that this revenue stream no longer plays the stabilising role it once did in State finances.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
While the Union Budget is keenly tracked by States to assess their share in overall Central tax devolution
Even though States watch the Central government’s budget very carefully to see how much tax money they will get back
Part 2
it
The situation (this is a placeholder for the idea that follows)
Part 3
is becoming
Is starting to be (shows a process happening right now)
Part 4
increasingly clear that this revenue stream no longer plays the stabilising role it once did in State finances
More and more obvious that this tax money from the Centre is not enough to keep State money matters steady like it used to
Sentence 2 of 18
The evidenceliesin the rapid expansion of State Development Loans (SDLs), which have emerged as a key financing instrument for States’ day-to-day spending needs.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
The evidence
The proof or the facts that show something is true
Part 2
lies
Can be found or exists (in something)
Part 3
in the rapid expansion of State Development Loans (SDLs), which have emerged as a key financing instrument for States’ day-to-day spending needs
In the fast growth of money that States borrow from the market, which has become a main way for them to pay for their regular daily expenses
Sentence 3 of 18
In 2024-25 (Revised Estimates),SDLsamountedto about 35% of Tamil Nadu’s total revenue receipts and nearly 26% of Maharashtra’s—levels that would have been considered fiscally exceptional a decade ago.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
In 2024-25 (Revised Estimates)
In the financial year 2024-2025, according to the updated calculations
Part 2
SDLs
State Development Loans (money borrowed by states)
Part 3
amounted
Reached the total value of or was equal to
Part 4
to about 35% of Tamil Nadu’s total revenue receipts and nearly 26% of Maharashtra’s
To nearly one-third of all the money Tamil Nadu earned and about one-fourth of Maharashtra’s total earnings
Part 5
levels that would have been considered fiscally exceptional a decade ago
Amounts that would have been seen as very unusual or very high ten years ago
Sentence 4 of 18
This shiftgatheredpaceafter 2020-21, when the COVID-19 pandemic delivered a severe economic shock and Central devolution proved inadequate.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
This shift
This change (referring to the increase in borrowing)
Part 2
gathered
Started to get more or collected (in this context, it means increased)
Part 3
pace
Speed (meaning the change happened faster)
Part 4
after 2020-21, when the COVID-19 pandemic delivered a severe economic shock and Central devolution proved inadequate
After the 2020-21 year, when the COVID-19 virus badly hurt the economy and the tax money from the Centre was not enough
Sentence 5 of 18
This dependence on borrowinghas not reversedsince.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
This dependence on borrowing
The need to keep taking loans to manage expenses
Part 2
has not reversed
Has not changed back to how it was before
Part 3
since
From that time until now
Sentence 6 of 18
Instead,Statesare increasingly relyingon SDLs;borrowings by profit-making State PSUs and Special Purpose Vehiclesare doneto finance even routine revenue expenditure.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
Instead
Rather than the situation getting better
Part 2
States
State governments in India
Part 3
are increasingly relying
Are using more and more (as their main source)
Part 4
on SDLs
On market loans (State Development Loans)
Part 5
borrowings by profit-making State PSUs and Special Purpose Vehicles
Loans taken by government-owned companies (that make money) and special groups set up for specific projects
Part 6
are done
Are being carried out or performed
Part 7
to finance even routine revenue expenditure
To pay for even regular, daily costs like salaries or repairs which should usually be paid from tax money
Sentence 7 of 18
Thishas happeneddespite the 15th Finance Commission fixing States’ share at 41% of the divisible pool,as the effective flow of resources has been eroded by the growing use of cesses and surcharges, which lie outside the divisible pool.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
This
This situation (increased borrowing by States)
Part 2
has happened
Has taken place or occurred
Part 3
despite the 15th Finance Commission fixing States’ share at 41% of the divisible pool
Even though the 15th Finance Commission said that States should get 41% of the shared tax money
Part 4
as the effective flow of resources has been eroded by the growing use of cesses and surcharges, which lie outside the divisible pool
Because the actual money going to States has decreased because the Centre is using more special taxes (cesses and surcharges) that it doesn’t have to share
Sentence 8 of 18
The problemisacute for industrialised States with a large indirect tax base.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
The problem
The issue of not getting enough shared tax money
Part 2
is
Is currently (describes the state of the problem)
Part 3
acute for industrialised States with a large indirect tax base
Very serious or severe for States that have many factories and businesses that pay a lot of GST
Sentence 9 of 18
Since the introduction of GST in 2017,a substantial share of these revenuesis collectedby the Centreandredistributedthrough a formula that often weakens the fiscal link between tax effort and reward.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
Since the introduction of GST in 2017
Starting from when the Goods and Services Tax was started in 2017
Part 2
a substantial share of these revenues
A large part of this tax money
Part 3
is collected
Is gathered or taken (by the government)
Part 4
by the Centre
By the Central Government
Part 5
redistributed
Shared out or given back again in a different way
Part 6
through a formula that often weakens the fiscal link between tax effort and reward
Using a math rule that often makes the connection between how much tax a State collects and how much it gets back weaker
Sentence 10 of 18
Consequently,welfare commitments — pensions for the elderly and retired employees and mass health insurance schemes for the poor —are increasingly being fundedthrough domestic borrowing.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
Consequently
As a result of this situation
Part 2
welfare commitments — pensions for the elderly and retired employees and mass health insurance schemes for the poor —
Government promises to help people, like giving monthly money to old people and former workers, and providing free health insurance for poor people
Part 3
are increasingly being funded
Are being paid for more and more (with a certain source of money)
Part 4
through domestic borrowing
By taking loans from within our own country (like from local banks)
Sentence 11 of 18
Thislimitsthe availability of funds for public capital expenditure and private investment, which is essential to sustain growth.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
This
This habit of using borrowed money for daily welfare expenses
Part 2
limits
Reduces or puts a stop to
Part 3
the availability of funds for public capital expenditure and private investment, which is essential to sustain growth
The amount of money left for building roads and bridges (public assets) and for private businesses to start new projects, which is needed to keep the country growing
Sentence 12 of 18
A comparison of borrowing patterns over the past five years across Punjab, Uttar Pradesh, Tamil Nadu, Maharashtra and West Bengalunderlinesthis trend.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
A comparison of borrowing patterns over the past five years across Punjab, Uttar Pradesh, Tamil Nadu, Maharashtra and West Bengal
Looking at how Punjab, Uttar Pradesh, Tamil Nadu, Maharashtra, and West Bengal have borrowed money over the last five years and comparing them
Part 2
underlines
Highlights or makes very clear
Part 3
this trend
This general direction or pattern (of increasing debt)
Sentence 13 of 18
West Bengal,which is structurally dependent on Central devolution — averaging about 47.7% of its revenue receipts over the last five years —continued to borrowheavily from the domestic market.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
West Bengal
The state of West Bengal
Part 2
which is structurally dependent on Central devolution — averaging about 47.7% of its revenue receipts over the last five years —
Which naturally relies on the shared tax money from the Centre (getting nearly half of its total income from the Centre on average for five years)
Part 3
continued to borrow
Kept on taking loans consistently
Part 4
heavily from the domestic market
Large amounts of money from the local financial market (banks, etc.)
Sentence 14 of 18
SDLsconstitutedroughly 35% of the State’s revenueson average during this period, even as nominal tax devolution rose.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
SDLs
State Development Loans (borrowed money)
Part 2
constituted
Made up or was equal to
Part 3
roughly 35% of the State’s revenues
About one-third of the total money West Bengal earned
Part 4
on average during this period, even as nominal tax devolution rose
During these five years, even though the actual number amount of tax money from the Centre went up
Sentence 15 of 18
Thispointsto a steady erosion of States’ fiscal autonomy, with potentially serious macroeconomic consequences as debt-to-GSDP ratios rise while assured revenue streams weaken.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
This
This data and trend of increasing borrowing
Part 2
points
Indicates or shows (towards a certain result)
Part 3
to a steady erosion of States’ fiscal autonomy, with potentially serious macroeconomic consequences as debt-to-GSDP ratios rise while assured revenue streams weaken
To a slow loss of the State’s power to manage its own money, which could hurt the whole economy as their debt becomes too high compared to their income, while their guaranteed income gets smaller
Sentence 16 of 18
If debt, rather than devolution, becomes the primary shock absorber in India’s federal system,fiscal sustainability itselfcomesunder strain.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
If debt, rather than devolution, becomes the primary shock absorber in India’s federal system
If taking loans, instead of getting shared tax money, becomes the main way to handle problems in India’s system of Centre and States
Part 2
fiscal sustainability itself
The very ability of the government to manage its money without failing in the future
Part 3
comes
Gets or enters a certain state
Part 4
under strain
Under pressure or difficulty
Sentence 17 of 18
Indianeedshigher effective devolution, and a reworking of horizontal devolution criteria to give greater weight to tax effort and efficiency.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
India
The country and its government system
Part 2
needs
Requires or must have (to improve something)
Part 3
higher effective devolution, and a reworking of horizontal devolution criteria to give greater weight to tax effort and efficiency
More actual tax money shared with States, and a change in the rules used to decide how much each State gets, so that States which collect taxes efficiently get more reward
Sentence 18 of 18
Cesses and surchargesmust be broughtinto the divisible pool.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
Cesses and surcharges
Special taxes that the Centre usually keeps for itself
Part 2
must be brought
Should be included or added (as a rule)
Part 3
into the divisible pool
Into the group of taxes that must be shared with the States
Reading Comprehension
Practice questions based on this editorial
Reading Comprehension - State Development Loans and Fiscal Federalism
Practice reading comprehension questions based on the editorial about the increasing reliance of Indian States on market borrowings and the challenges of tax devolution.
Scoreclever helps you master Current Affairs, English Language, and General Awareness for all Banking, SSC, Railway, and Defence exams. The Scoreclever app has innovative learning techniques that make memorization and revision effortless.