Sentence 1 of 18
The rehearsal for the second phase of Census 2027, under way in 16 States and Union Territories since July 6, carries a key feature: an “open column” where respondents can state their caste, which the enumerator will record.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
The rehearsal for the second phase of Census 2027
The trial run or practice exercise for the next part of India’s official population count scheduled for 2027
Part 2
under way in 16 States and Union Territories since July 6
currently happening across 16 different provinces and regions of India since the 6th of July
Part 3
carries
includes or contains
Part 4
a key feature: an “open column” where respondents can state their caste, which the enumerator will record
an important part where people answering questions can type or say any caste name they choose, and the government worker will write it down exactly
Sentence 2 of 18
Unlike the 2011 Socio-Economic and Caste Census (SECC), which also had this feature, this counting of caste in the Census itself has statutory backing.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
Unlike the 2011 Socio-Economic and Caste Census (SECC), which also had this feature
In contrast to the 2011 socio-economic study which similarly recorded people’s castes
Part 2
this counting of caste in the Census itself
recording people’s caste status within the main national population count itself
Part 3
has
possesses or enjoys
Part 4
statutory backing
support or authorization from a formal law passed by the parliament
Sentence 3 of 18
The pre-test ends on July 20, and the government says that it will then finalise the methodology for counting caste.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
The pre-test
The practice or preliminary census run currently being conducted
Part 2
ends
comes to a close or finishes
Part 3
on July 20
on the twentieth day of July
Part 4
the government
The ruling administration (central government of India)
Part 5
says
states or declares
Part 6
that it will then finalise the methodology for counting caste
that they will decide on the official rules and steps to record people’s castes after the practice run is over
Sentence 4 of 18
The hope is that the pre-test findings will corroborate what is known: an open-ended response on caste yields only unwieldy data, as seen in the 2011 SECC, which eventually proved unusable.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
The hope
The expectation or desired outcome
Part 3
that the pre-test findings will corroborate what is known: an open-ended response on caste yields only unwieldy data, as seen in the 2011 SECC, which eventually proved unusable
that the results of this practice run will confirm what we already know: letting people write whatever they want for caste creates messy and disorganized information, just like in 2011 when the collected data could not be used at all
Sentence 5 of 18
It is not difficult to understand why.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
It
The reason for the data being unusable
Part 3
not difficult
easy or straightforward
Part 4
to understand why
to see the reasons behind this problem
Sentence 6 of 18
The method led the 2011 SECC to return more than 46 lakh “caste names”, against the 4,147 in the 1931 Census, the last to tabulate caste.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
The method
The open-ended way of collecting caste names (where respondents wrote anything they wanted)
Part 2
led
caused or guided
Part 3
the 2011 SECC
The 2011 Socio-Economic and Caste Census exercise
Part 4
to return more than 46 lakh “caste names”
to produce and list over 4.6 million different names for castes
Part 5
against the 4,147 in the 1931 Census, the last to tabulate caste
compared to only 4,147 actual castes registered in the 1931 census, which was the last time the British government categorized and published full caste data
Sentence 7 of 18
Respondents entered surnames, sub-castes and clan names as if interchangeable, inflating the count into incoherence.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
Respondents
The citizens answering the census questionnaires
Part 2
entered
wrote down or inputted
Part 3
surnames, sub-castes and clan names
last names, smaller subdivisions of castes, and family ancestry titles
Part 4
as if interchangeable, inflating the count into incoherence
as though all these terms meant the exact same thing, causing the total number of recorded castes to increase so much that the data became completely confusing and meaningless
Sentence 8 of 18
The Centre told the Supreme Court in 2021 that the SECC figures were too error-ridden to be relied upon for reservation.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
The Centre
The central government of India
Part 2
told
informed or declared to
Part 3
the Supreme Court
The highest judicial court in India
Part 4
in 2021
during the year two thousand twenty-one
Part 5
that the SECC figures were too error-ridden to be relied upon for reservation
that the data from the 2011 Socio-Economic and Caste Census had too many mistakes and could not be trusted to decide quotas (reservations) in jobs or education
Sentence 9 of 18
The pre-test should instead point to a better method — using the digital Census’s hand-held devices, pre-loaded with a curated list of castes and sub-castes, so that the enumerator selects the ‘correct’ entry after asking the respondent.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
The pre-test
The trial run of the census
Part 2
should instead point
ought to guide or direct attention
Part 3
to a better method
towards a more effective way of doing things
Part 4
— using the digital Census’s hand-held devices, pre-loaded with a curated list of castes and sub-castes, so that the enumerator selects the ‘correct’ entry after asking the respondent
by having census workers use mobile tablets or phones containing a pre-existing, carefully checked list of castes, allowing them to pick the right option based on what the citizen says
Sentence 10 of 18
Mistakes and mismatches will happen, but as the 2022-23 Bihar caste survey revealed, this method could return more usable data.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
Mistakes and mismatches
Errors in entering data and conflicts between different entries
Part 2
will happen
are certain to occur
Part 3
as the 2022-23 Bihar caste survey revealed
in the way shown by the caste study conducted in Bihar state during 2022 and 2023
Part 4
this method
The curated list method using pre-loaded digital devices
Part 5
could return
has the potential to yield or produce
Part 6
more usable data
information that is far cleaner, more accurate, and actually helpful for public planning
Sentence 11 of 18
Unlike the other identities — linguistic, religious and gender — that the Census notes, caste is an abstract, irrational one that designates people not by biological, physical, or professed attributes, but by a perceived, primordial identity conferred at birth and arranged in a hierarchy.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
Unlike the other identities — linguistic, religious and gender — that the Census notes
In contrast to other categories recorded in the census, such as language spoken, religion practiced, and sex
Part 2
caste
The system of social division in India based on birth
Part 4
an abstract, irrational one that designates people not by biological, physical, or professed attributes, but by a perceived, primordial identity conferred at birth and arranged in a hierarchy
a non-physical, illogical concept that categorizes individuals not by their biology, bodily traits, or chosen beliefs, but by an ancient, perceived division assigned at birth and organized into an unequal rank order
Sentence 12 of 18
Even this hierarchy is not self-evident, with the perceptions of social status of different castes often contradicting one another.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
Even this hierarchy
Even this ranked system of castes
Part 3
not self-evident
not obvious or accepted by everyone without proof
Part 4
with the perceptions of social status of different castes often contradicting one another
because different caste groups have views about their own and others’ social rank that frequently clash or disagree with each other
Sentence 13 of 18
India’s Constitution, committed to social justice, set itself against caste by abolishing untouchability, forbidding caste-based discrimination and holding out the promise of a republic where birth would not determine a citizen’s standing.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
India’s Constitution
The supreme law book and governing framework of India
Part 2
committed to social justice
dedicated to ensuring fairness, equality, and support for all members of society
Part 3
set
positioned or aligned
Part 4
itself
the Constitution itself
Part 5
against caste
in opposition to the caste system
Part 6
by abolishing untouchability, forbidding caste-based discrimination and holding out the promise of a republic where birth would not determine a citizen’s standing
by legally ending the practice of social exclusion (untouchability), banning unfair treatment based on caste, and offering the hope of a nation where a person’s family of birth does not decide their value or status
Sentence 14 of 18
So why count caste when the very act of enumeration can ossify or reify this abstract identity?
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
So why
For what reason, then
Part 2
count
calculate, list, or tabulate
Part 3
caste
social groups based on birth hierarchy
Part 4
when the very act of enumeration can ossify or reify this abstract identity
considering that the process of counting people by caste might make this non-physical, socially constructed identity permanent and rigid (ossify) or treat it as a concrete, objective reality (reify)
Sentence 15 of 18
The only rationale is that self-perceived or imposed caste identity creates social inequities, and welfare and social justice measures that address caste-based injustice can, over time, be expected to delegitimise the casteism rather than entrench it.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
The only rationale
The sole logical reason or justification
Part 3
that self-perceived or imposed caste identity creates social inequities, and welfare and social justice measures that address caste-based injustice can, over time, be expected to delegitimise the casteism rather than entrench it
that our own feeling of caste or the caste label forced on us by society causes unfair social differences, and that helper programs and justice actions aimed at fixing caste unfairness are hoped, eventually, to make caste discrimination lose its authority and meaning instead of making it stronger or permanent
Sentence 16 of 18
Through sharper targeting of welfare and affirmative action, empirical caste data can also inform questions of the creamy layer and the sub-categorisation of castes and classes already benefiting from reservation.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
Through sharper targeting of welfare and affirmative action
By making sure that welfare benefits and reservations reach the exact people who need them the most
Part 2
empirical caste data
Caste information based on real-world observation and facts rather than theory
Part 3
can also inform
can help explain or guide decisions about
Part 4
questions of the creamy layer and the sub-categorisation of castes and classes already benefiting from reservation
debates and issues regarding which rich individuals (creamy layer) should be excluded from benefits, and how to divide larger groups into smaller sub-groups (sub-categorisation) so benefits are shared fairly among those already getting help
Sentence 17 of 18
In these, better data are indispensable.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
In these
In these matters or decisions (creamy layer and sub-categorisation)
Part 2
better data
more accurate and reliable information
Part 4
indispensable
absolutely necessary; that you cannot do without
Sentence 18 of 18
If caste is to be counted, it should be counted well.
Sentence Breakdown
Part 1
If caste is to be counted
If the government is going to make the choice to calculate and record people’s caste
Part 2
it
the counting process / the caste
Part 3
should be counted
ought to be calculated and recorded
Part 4
well
properly, accurately, and with a reliable methodology