The perspicacious judgment of the Supreme Court last week encapsulating the right to menstrual health and hygiene into the fundamental right to life and dignity under Article 21 of the Constitutionisprecisely the kind of intervention needed,with all the power of Thor’s hammer.
Simple PresentS + V + C + AdjunctMain ClauseSimple Sentence
Phrase Breakdown
SubjectWho/What
The perspicacious judgment of the Supreme Court last week encapsulating the right to menstrual health and hygiene into the fundamental right to life and dignity under Article 21 of the Constitution
The wise decision made by the top court last week which made menstrual health a basic right under the laws of the country.
VerbWhat is happening
is
Is (describes the current status or state).
ComplementCompletes meaning
precisely the kind of intervention needed
Exactly the type of action that was required to fix the current situation.
AdjunctAdditional info
with all the power of Thor’s hammer
With incredible strength and authority, like the powerful weapon used by a legendary hero.
Context and Background
Article 21 and the Supreme Court
Article 21 of the Indian Constitution is the most widely interpreted fundamental right. The Supreme Court has previously held that ‘life’ does not just mean existing, but living with ‘dignity’. By including menstrual health under Article 21, the court has given it the highest legal protection, making it a duty for the government to ensure every girl has these facilities.
Sentence 2 of 15
English Original
A Bench of Justices J.B. Pardiwala and R. Mahadevanwrotein their sterling judgment that takes a rare, rights-based, 360 degree view of the problem:“Autonomy can be meaningfully exercised only when girl children have access to functional toilets, adequate menstrual products, availability of water, and hygienic mechanisms for disposal.”
Simple PastS + V + Adjunct + ObjectMain ClauseComplex Sentence
Phrase Breakdown
SubjectWho/What
A Bench of Justices J.B. Pardiwala and R. Mahadevan
A team of two Supreme Court judges, Justice Pardiwala and Justice Mahadevan.
VerbWhat is happening
wrote
Wrote (recorded their decision in writing).
AdjunctAdditional info
in their sterling judgment that takes a rare, rights-based, 360 degree view of the problem
In their excellent legal decision that looks at the issue thoroughly from all sides, focusing on human rights.
ObjectWhat receives action
“Autonomy can be meaningfully exercised only when girl children have access to functional toilets, adequate menstrual products, availability of water, and hygienic mechanisms for disposal.”
“A girl can truly have control over her life only when she has working toilets, enough pads, water, and clean ways to throw away waste.”
Context and Background
Comprehensive Health Rights
A ‘rights-based’ approach means looking at menstrual hygiene not just as a health issue, but as a legal right that girls are entitled to. A 360 degree view implies that the court didn’t just look at providing pads, but also at toilets, water, and waste management, all of which are necessary for proper hygiene.
Sentence 3 of 15
English Original
Shifting the onus,the judgescalled uponthe stateto make menstrual health accessible to all girls and remove the triptych of stigma, stereotyping and humiliation that girls who do not have access to these facilities are regularly subject to.
Simple PastAdjunct + S + V + O + AdjunctMain ClauseComplex Sentence
Phrase Breakdown
AdjunctAdditional info
Shifting the onus
Moving the responsibility (from individual girls to the government).
SubjectWho/What
the judges
The members of the Supreme Court bench.
VerbWhat is happening
called upon
Asked or ordered (officially).
ObjectWhat receives action
the state
The government (including both Central and State levels).
AdjunctAdditional info
to make menstrual health accessible to all girls and remove the triptych of stigma, stereotyping and humiliation that girls who do not have access to these facilities are regularly subject to
To ensure every girl can get hygiene help and to stop the three problems of shame, wrong ideas, and embarrassment that girls without these facilities face.
Sentence 4 of 15
English Original
The judgesnotedthat this violates the bodily autonomy of menstruating girl children.
Simple PastS + V + OMain ClauseComplex Sentence
Phrase Breakdown
SubjectWho/What
The judges
The legal experts of the Supreme Court who heard the case.
VerbWhat is happening
noted
Observed or pointed out.
ObjectWhat receives action
that this violates the bodily autonomy of menstruating girl children
That the lack of facilities breaks the right of young girls to have control over their own bodies during their periods.
Sentence 5 of 15
English Original
Terming it as ‘menstrual poverty’,the Benchsaidthat it hinders menstruating girls from exercising their right to education with dignity equal to their male counterparts, or students who can afford sanitary products.
Simple PastAdjunct + S + V + OMain ClauseComplex Sentence
Phrase Breakdown
AdjunctAdditional info
Terming it as ‘menstrual poverty’
Calling the problem ‘menstrual poverty’.
SubjectWho/What
the Bench
The group of Supreme Court judges.
VerbWhat is happening
said
Stated or explained.
ObjectWhat receives action
that it hinders menstruating girls from exercising their right to education with dignity equal to their male counterparts, or students who can afford sanitary products
That this problem stops girls from going to school with the same respect as boys or students who have the money to buy pads.
Context and Background
Impact of Period Poverty
Period poverty is a major reason for school dropouts among adolescent girls in India. Without access to pads or toilets, girls often stay home during their periods to avoid embarrassment, leading to them falling behind in their studies and eventually leaving school altogether.
Sentence 6 of 15
English Original
The CourtorderedStates and Union Territoriesto ensure that every school has functional, gender-segregated toilets,andwrote inpunitive action for non-compliance.
to ensure that every school has functional, gender-segregated toilets
To make sure every school has working toilets that are separate for boys and girls.
VerbWhat is happening
wrote in
Included as part of the legal order.
ObjectWhat receives action
punitive action for non-compliance
Legal punishment for those who do not follow the court’s orders.
Sentence 7 of 15
English Original
The statewill be heldaccountableif government-run schools did not comply,andprivate schoolscan be derecognised.
Simple FutureCompound Sentence (S+V+C+Adjunct and S+V)Main ClauseCompound-Complex Sentence
Phrase Breakdown
SubjectWho/What
The state
The government.
VerbWhat is happening
will be held
Will be made (in the future).
ComplementCompletes meaning
accountable
Responsible for answering why something was not done.
AdjunctAdditional info
if government-run schools did not comply
In case schools managed by the government do not follow the orders.
SubjectWho/What
private schools
Schools that are not run by the government.
VerbWhat is happening
can be derecognised
Can lose their official permission to operate.
Sentence 8 of 15
English Original
The lack of access to health-care products during menstruation, even clean water and toilets,arisesfrom a clear, gendered lack of equity.
Simple PresentS + V + AdjunctMain ClauseSimple Sentence
Phrase Breakdown
SubjectWho/What
The lack of access to health-care products during menstruation, even clean water and toilets
The problem where girls cannot get pads, clean water, or toilets during their periods.
VerbWhat is happening
arises
Starts or comes from.
AdjunctAdditional info
from a clear, gendered lack of equity
From a very obvious situation where resources are not shared fairly between men and women.
Sentence 9 of 15
English Original
While the National Family Health Survey (NFHS)-5 data claim that the percentage of women aged 15-24 years using hygienic methods during their menstrual cycles has risen to 77.3% in NFHS-5 from 57.6% in NFHS-4,itstill leavesabout a fourth of all women of eligible age in the countryadrift, without support.
Simple PresentAdjunct + S + V + O + ComplementMain ClauseComplex Sentence
Phrase Breakdown
AdjunctAdditional info
While the National Family Health Survey (NFHS)-5 data claim that the percentage of women aged 15-24 years using hygienic methods during their menstrual cycles has risen to 77.3% in NFHS-5 from 57.6% in NFHS-4
Even though survey data shows that more young women (77.3%) are now using clean methods compared to before (57.6%).
SubjectWho/What
it
The current situation or the remaining gap.
VerbWhat is happening
still leaves
Continues to keep (someone in a certain state).
ObjectWhat receives action
about a fourth of all women of eligible age in the country
Almost 25% of young women in India.
ComplementCompletes meaning
adrift, without support
Alone and without any help or guidance.
Context and Background
NFHS Data on Menstrual Hygiene
The National Family Health Survey (NFHS) is an important data source for India. NFHS-4 was done in 2015-16 and NFHS-5 in 2019-21. While the increase to 77.3% is good news, it means that nearly 1 in 4 young women still lack access to basic hygiene products, which is a significant number in a country as large as India.
Sentence 10 of 15
English Original
While the Ministry of Drinking Water and Sanitation under the Swachh Bharat Abhiyan has said that it has developed guidelines on menstrual hygiene management for creating awareness in rural areas,implementationhas always beenpatchyandthe energyisproject-based, not sustained.
While the Ministry of Drinking Water and Sanitation under the Swachh Bharat Abhiyan has said that it has developed guidelines on menstrual hygiene management for creating awareness in rural areas
Even though the government department in charge of clean water has made rules for period hygiene and teaching people in villages.
SubjectWho/What
implementation
How the rules are actually put into action.
VerbWhat is happening
has always been
Has been (in the past and still is).
ComplementCompletes meaning
patchy
Not consistent; good in some places but very bad in others.
SubjectWho/What
the energy
The effort and focus put into the work.
VerbWhat is happening
is
Is (currently).
ComplementCompletes meaning
project-based, not sustained
Done as individual short-term tasks rather than a permanent, long-lasting plan.
Context and Background
Swachh Bharat Abhiyan and Menstrual Hygiene
The Swachh Bharat Abhiyan (SBA) is a major cleanliness drive in India. While SBA has built millions of toilets, the management of menstrual hygiene (including providing pads and educating girls) often lacks a permanent budget and plan, leading to the ‘patchy’ results mentioned in the editorial.
Sentence 11 of 15
English Original
Fragmented, though well-meaning, efforts by non-governmental organisationshave formedthe bulk of interventionsfor years now,butthe ability to erase the stigmarequiresa larger force to act.
Fragmented, though well-meaning, efforts by non-governmental organisations
Separate and uncoordinated actions taken by private charities, even though they have good intentions.
VerbWhat is happening
have formed
Have made up or been.
ObjectWhat receives action
the bulk of interventions
The largest part of the work being done to help.
AdjunctAdditional info
for years now
For many years up to the present time.
SubjectWho/What
the ability to erase the stigma
The power to completely remove the shame or embarrassment attached to periods.
VerbWhat is happening
requires
Needs.
ObjectWhat receives action
a larger force to act
A more powerful authority (like the Supreme Court or Central Government) to take action.
Sentence 12 of 15
English Original
Menstrual healthisnot just a woman’s issue but a public health and human rights issue.
Simple PresentS + V + CMain ClauseSimple Sentence
Phrase Breakdown
SubjectWho/What
Menstrual health
The state of complete physical, mental, and social well-being in all matters relating to the menstrual cycle.
VerbWhat is happening
is
Is (describing its nature).
ComplementCompletes meaning
not just a woman’s issue but a public health and human rights issue
Something that affects the health of the entire society and is also about basic rights that every person should have.
Sentence 13 of 15
English Original
With the judgmentthereisfinally a chance of that happening.
Simple PresentAdjunct + S + V + CMain ClauseSimple Sentence
Phrase Breakdown
AdjunctAdditional info
With the judgment
Because of the Supreme Court’s decision.
SubjectWho/What
there
There (used to introduce a new fact or situation).
VerbWhat is happening
is
Is (currently exists).
ComplementCompletes meaning
finally a chance of that happening
At last, a possibility that the problem will be solved.
Sentence 14 of 15
English Original
Commitment from a policy and financial perspective alonecan ensuremenstrual hygiene for all young girls and womenandenablethemto achieve their full potential.
Taking an idea from the famous saying of an organization called The Pad Project.
ObjectWhat receives action
“A period should end a sentence, not a girl’s education.”
“A ‘period’ should only be a stop at the end of a written sentence, and it should never be the reason a girl has to stop her schooling.”
Context and Background
The Pad Project
The Pad Project is a global organization that famously produced the Oscar-winning documentary ‘Period. End of Sentence.’ The motto mentioned here uses a clever play on words (pun): a ‘period’ is something that stops a sentence in writing, but in real life, a girl’s menstrual period often unfairly stops her from getting an education. The judges used this quote to emphasize that biology should not be a barrier to learning.
Sentence 1 of 15
Sentence 1 of 15
The perspicacious judgment of the Supreme Court last week encapsulating the right to menstrual health and hygiene into the fundamental right to life and dignity under Article 21 of the Constitutionisprecisely the kind of intervention needed,with all the power of Thor’s hammer.
Phrase Breakdown
Subject
The perspicacious judgment of the Supreme Court last week encapsulating the right to menstrual health and hygiene into the fundamental right to life and dignity under Article 21 of the Constitution
The wise decision made by the top court last week which made menstrual health a basic right under the laws of the country.
Verb
is
Is (describes the current status or state).
Complement
precisely the kind of intervention needed
Exactly the type of action that was required to fix the current situation.
Adjunct
with all the power of Thor’s hammer
With incredible strength and authority, like the powerful weapon used by a legendary hero.
Sentence 2 of 15
A Bench of Justices J.B. Pardiwala and R. Mahadevanwrotein their sterling judgment that takes a rare, rights-based, 360 degree view of the problem:“Autonomy can be meaningfully exercised only when girl children have access to functional toilets, adequate menstrual products, availability of water, and hygienic mechanisms for disposal.”
Phrase Breakdown
Subject
A Bench of Justices J.B. Pardiwala and R. Mahadevan
A team of two Supreme Court judges, Justice Pardiwala and Justice Mahadevan.
Verb
wrote
Wrote (recorded their decision in writing).
Adjunct
in their sterling judgment that takes a rare, rights-based, 360 degree view of the problem
In their excellent legal decision that looks at the issue thoroughly from all sides, focusing on human rights.
Object
“Autonomy can be meaningfully exercised only when girl children have access to functional toilets, adequate menstrual products, availability of water, and hygienic mechanisms for disposal.”
“A girl can truly have control over her life only when she has working toilets, enough pads, water, and clean ways to throw away waste.”
Sentence 3 of 15
Shifting the onus,the judgescalled uponthe stateto make menstrual health accessible to all girls and remove the triptych of stigma, stereotyping and humiliation that girls who do not have access to these facilities are regularly subject to.
Phrase Breakdown
Adjunct
Shifting the onus
Moving the responsibility (from individual girls to the government).
Subject
the judges
The members of the Supreme Court bench.
Verb
called upon
Asked or ordered (officially).
Object
the state
The government (including both Central and State levels).
Adjunct
to make menstrual health accessible to all girls and remove the triptych of stigma, stereotyping and humiliation that girls who do not have access to these facilities are regularly subject to
To ensure every girl can get hygiene help and to stop the three problems of shame, wrong ideas, and embarrassment that girls without these facilities face.
Sentence 4 of 15
The judgesnotedthat this violates the bodily autonomy of menstruating girl children.
Phrase Breakdown
Subject
The judges
The legal experts of the Supreme Court who heard the case.
Verb
noted
Observed or pointed out.
Object
that this violates the bodily autonomy of menstruating girl children
That the lack of facilities breaks the right of young girls to have control over their own bodies during their periods.
Sentence 5 of 15
Terming it as ‘menstrual poverty’,the Benchsaidthat it hinders menstruating girls from exercising their right to education with dignity equal to their male counterparts, or students who can afford sanitary products.
Phrase Breakdown
Adjunct
Terming it as ‘menstrual poverty’
Calling the problem ‘menstrual poverty’.
Subject
the Bench
The group of Supreme Court judges.
Verb
said
Stated or explained.
Object
that it hinders menstruating girls from exercising their right to education with dignity equal to their male counterparts, or students who can afford sanitary products
That this problem stops girls from going to school with the same respect as boys or students who have the money to buy pads.
Sentence 6 of 15
The CourtorderedStates and Union Territoriesto ensure that every school has functional, gender-segregated toilets,andwrote inpunitive action for non-compliance.
Phrase Breakdown
Subject
The Court
The Supreme Court of India.
Verb
ordered
Officially commanded.
Object
States and Union Territories
The various regional governments across India.
Adjunct
to ensure that every school has functional, gender-segregated toilets
To make sure every school has working toilets that are separate for boys and girls.
Verb
wrote in
Included as part of the legal order.
Object
punitive action for non-compliance
Legal punishment for those who do not follow the court’s orders.
Sentence 7 of 15
The statewill be heldaccountableif government-run schools did not comply,andprivate schoolscan be derecognised.
Phrase Breakdown
Subject
The state
The government.
Verb
will be held
Will be made (in the future).
Complement
accountable
Responsible for answering why something was not done.
Adjunct
if government-run schools did not comply
In case schools managed by the government do not follow the orders.
Subject
private schools
Schools that are not run by the government.
Verb
can be derecognised
Can lose their official permission to operate.
Sentence 8 of 15
The lack of access to health-care products during menstruation, even clean water and toilets,arisesfrom a clear, gendered lack of equity.
Phrase Breakdown
Subject
The lack of access to health-care products during menstruation, even clean water and toilets
The problem where girls cannot get pads, clean water, or toilets during their periods.
Verb
arises
Starts or comes from.
Adjunct
from a clear, gendered lack of equity
From a very obvious situation where resources are not shared fairly between men and women.
Sentence 9 of 15
While the National Family Health Survey (NFHS)-5 data claim that the percentage of women aged 15-24 years using hygienic methods during their menstrual cycles has risen to 77.3% in NFHS-5 from 57.6% in NFHS-4,itstill leavesabout a fourth of all women of eligible age in the countryadrift, without support.
Phrase Breakdown
Adjunct
While the National Family Health Survey (NFHS)-5 data claim that the percentage of women aged 15-24 years using hygienic methods during their menstrual cycles has risen to 77.3% in NFHS-5 from 57.6% in NFHS-4
Even though survey data shows that more young women (77.3%) are now using clean methods compared to before (57.6%).
Subject
it
The current situation or the remaining gap.
Verb
still leaves
Continues to keep (someone in a certain state).
Object
about a fourth of all women of eligible age in the country
Almost 25% of young women in India.
Complement
adrift, without support
Alone and without any help or guidance.
Sentence 10 of 15
While the Ministry of Drinking Water and Sanitation under the Swachh Bharat Abhiyan has said that it has developed guidelines on menstrual hygiene management for creating awareness in rural areas,implementationhas always beenpatchyandthe energyisproject-based, not sustained.
Phrase Breakdown
Adjunct
While the Ministry of Drinking Water and Sanitation under the Swachh Bharat Abhiyan has said that it has developed guidelines on menstrual hygiene management for creating awareness in rural areas
Even though the government department in charge of clean water has made rules for period hygiene and teaching people in villages.
Subject
implementation
How the rules are actually put into action.
Verb
has always been
Has been (in the past and still is).
Complement
patchy
Not consistent; good in some places but very bad in others.
Subject
the energy
The effort and focus put into the work.
Verb
is
Is (currently).
Complement
project-based, not sustained
Done as individual short-term tasks rather than a permanent, long-lasting plan.
Sentence 11 of 15
Fragmented, though well-meaning, efforts by non-governmental organisationshave formedthe bulk of interventionsfor years now,butthe ability to erase the stigmarequiresa larger force to act.
Phrase Breakdown
Subject
Fragmented, though well-meaning, efforts by non-governmental organisations
Separate and uncoordinated actions taken by private charities, even though they have good intentions.
Verb
have formed
Have made up or been.
Object
the bulk of interventions
The largest part of the work being done to help.
Adjunct
for years now
For many years up to the present time.
Subject
the ability to erase the stigma
The power to completely remove the shame or embarrassment attached to periods.
Verb
requires
Needs.
Object
a larger force to act
A more powerful authority (like the Supreme Court or Central Government) to take action.
Sentence 12 of 15
Menstrual healthisnot just a woman’s issue but a public health and human rights issue.
Phrase Breakdown
Subject
Menstrual health
The state of complete physical, mental, and social well-being in all matters relating to the menstrual cycle.
Verb
is
Is (describing its nature).
Complement
not just a woman’s issue but a public health and human rights issue
Something that affects the health of the entire society and is also about basic rights that every person should have.
Sentence 13 of 15
With the judgmentthereisfinally a chance of that happening.
Phrase Breakdown
Adjunct
With the judgment
Because of the Supreme Court’s decision.
Subject
there
There (used to introduce a new fact or situation).
Verb
is
Is (currently exists).
Complement
finally a chance of that happening
At last, a possibility that the problem will be solved.
Sentence 14 of 15
Commitment from a policy and financial perspective alonecan ensuremenstrual hygiene for all young girls and womenandenablethemto achieve their full potential.
Phrase Breakdown
Subject
Commitment from a policy and financial perspective alone
Only a strong promise from the government in terms of laws and money.
Verb
can ensure
Can make sure of.
Object
menstrual hygiene for all young girls and women
Clean and safe period facilities for every girl and woman.
Verb
enable
Make it possible for (someone to do something).
Object
them
The young girls and women.
Complement
to achieve their full potential
To reach their highest level of success and ability in life.
Sentence 15 of 15
As the judges said,inspired by the motto of The Pad Project:“A period should end a sentence, not a girl’s education.”
Phrase Breakdown
Adjunct
As the judges said
Just like the members of the court stated.
Adjunct
inspired by the motto of The Pad Project
Taking an idea from the famous saying of an organization called The Pad Project.
Object
“A period should end a sentence, not a girl’s education.”
“A ‘period’ should only be a stop at the end of a written sentence, and it should never be the reason a girl has to stop her schooling.”
Reading Comprehension
Practice questions based on this editorial
Reading Comprehension - Menstrual Health Rights
Practice reading comprehension questions based on the editorial about the Supreme Court's judgment on the right to menstrual health and hygiene.
Scoreclever helps you master Current Affairs, English Language, and General Awareness for all Banking, SSC, Railway, and Defence exams. The Scoreclever app has innovative learning techniques that make memorization and revision effortless.